play pretend — draco malfoy
pairing: draco malfoy x female!reader
prompt: in which two people are forced into marriage; reader falls in love. draco doesn’t.
a/n: hi listen to the song dusk til dawn if you wanna get into ur feelings while reading this .. anyways enjoy!!!
No matter how much Draco tried to deny it, part of her had always known that unwanted feelings lingered. Feelings from the past that should have been left there but weren’t—feelings that shone through during the most intimate moments; underneath bed covers, when Astoria’s name would slip past his lips instead of hers, or afternoons spent out by the garden when she would catch his eye and find him looking at her in a way that made it so painfully obvious that he was trying to find something in her that he could love.
The first time his and [Y/N]’s families had ever met, Narcissa Malfoy had pulled her away from the dining table to tell her in a voice of caution about a girl named Astoria Greengrass; the very same one Draco had fallen in love with during his time at Hogwarts. The girl came from a wealthy family, but one that was not wealthy enough—her blood was pure but her name not as well-respected as that of the Malfoys’ (word had leaked of an early ancestor having married a Muggle). Simply put, she was, though close to it, not good enough for Draco. The history of her family line and her insufficient wealth just couldn’t make the cut; Astoria Greengrass wasn’t good enough to wed into the Malfoy family—regardless of how much Draco claimed to have felt for her.
And so Astoria and Draco’s story ended with tragedy; with separation and arranged marriages to anyone but each other. Astoria wedded a man of her status; someone who could afford to marry her, and Draco to [Y/N], who had never known love until she met him—the very person who couldn’t feel the same for her.
She’d wedded Draco fully aware that mutual feelings of affection were the last of any of their families’ concerns. As long as no Muggle blood besmirched each others’ family trees and the purity of blood was carried on further into newer generations, petty things like love hardly mattered.
Except somewhere along their forced time together in a lonely manor by the countryside—a dowry from her family to the Malfoys—[Y/N] began to look at Draco as less of the man who had been forced into marriage with her and more of a man she could learn to love. And so she did; she learned and loved and found a comfort in him that she had never been expecting to. It took time, yes, but once she took that courageous step and the floor gave out underneath her feet and she fell for Draco faster than she could even blink, she couldn’t stop.
Because once you start to love someone, you are done for. You won’t be able to pull yourself back out.
Maybe that’s why Draco can’t forget that one Astoria Greengrass. Maybe that’s why he can’t quite look at [Y/N] the way she wants him to. Maybe it’s why, when [Y/N] foolishly tells him “I love you” in hopes that maybe this time he’ll say it back, he doesn’t.
[Y/N] wants to be angry. She wants to be able to grasp Draco’s shoulders, shake him to his senses and scream at him to forget Astoria, you can never have each other but you have me and I love you and I want you to be able to say the same for me so please just let go of her. But to set her pride aside and ask something like that of him takes plenty of courage—courage that [Y/N] isn’t entirely sure she has.
So she sits and pretends like everything is fine. Tells herself that the man she loves loves her back when she knows he doesn’t. And he knows it too.
Playing pretend—she’s gotten quite good at it over time.
—
When Draco holds her at midnight and presses himself close to her, it’s like he’s trying to imprint himself onto her very skin, trying to ingrain part of himself onto every inch of her body he can reach. And in a way, he does, in patches of faint red and purple and dark blues that mark her skin wherever his lips go.
They almost never talk at night. They’re much too busy wrapped up in each other’s arms and legs to bother with words. [Y/N] threads her fingers through his hair and pulls him in and Draco kisses her so hard it’s like he’s trying to make up for everything that he can’t give her; kisses with passion that isn’t quite driven by love but rather desperation for something—someone—he can’t quite have.
And it hurts because [Y/N] knows that when Draco groans into her mouth and tightens his grip on her waist and glides his lips down her skin, it’s not her face in his head. And it’s not her name that leaves his lips, either, when the night progresses and they are drunk in one another’s touch.
But [Y/N] is okay with it—or so she tells herself.
She has Draco. She’s happy. She loves him, even though he doesn’t. She is happy.
She has to be.
—
Jealousy.
That’s what [Y/N] feels.
[Y/N] has never met Astoria Greengrass but she is pathetically jealous of her. She is jealous of everything about Astoria that Draco fell in love with, whatever that might be. And it’s ridiculous because she doesn’t even know what she looks like or how she is; all that [Y/N] knows about her is that she must truly be something else to have captured Draco Malfoy’s heart and to still have it in her hands after all of this time.
An arranged marriage and a year forced apart—you’d think that that would be enough for Draco to move on.
They’ve been together for a while. Draco still looks at her like he’s not really seeing her. He doesn’t love her, and [Y/N] isn’t exactly sure he ever will. Every day she wakes and hopes that by some miracle he has opened his eyes and has begun to finally see past the future she knows he still fantasizes about with Astoria, but that is yet to happen. For now [Y/N] is helplessly in love with a man who has his heart set on someone else.
And at some point she has become angry, but not at Draco nor the woman he loves—no, she is angry at herself. She catches sight of herself in the mirror and hates what is staring back at her. She goes up to her reflection and frowns and contemplates what it is she’s missing. If the sight of her own face is revolting to herself, then it is no doubt that others feel the same way—including Draco—and is that why he can’t love her? Because of how ugly she is? Or is it how she acts? How she speaks, how she laughs, how she smiles, how she is?
Whenever Draco disappears to “clear his head” and [Y/N] is left alone, she finds that the manor is too small to hold the vast amount of nothingness spilling out of her at the seams, so she goes out into the highest balcony that overlooks the sea and breathes in as much of the salty breeze as she can until the feeling in her chest doesn’t quite feel as suffocating anymore.
It’s not the marriage she’d been hoping for all of those years ago when she was a naive child who believed in fairy tales and happy endings. But at the very least, she loves. And she is grateful to Draco for allowing her to know what that feels like, even when he can’t quite give it back to her.
—
But hearts are made of soft things, tissue and blood and muscle. Things that break and wound easy. Things that tend to scar instead of heal. There is only so much you can do until a human reaches breaking point and their heart gives away, and [Y/N] finds herself one Thursday evening with blood dripping down her knuckles and shards of glass scattered on the floor.
“What happened?” Draco’s voice is soft, imploring, almost loving but not quite. It’s always almost. Almost what [Y/N] wants. Almost how a husband should love his wife. Almost.
“Tripped,” [Y/N] winces. Draco kneels down in front of her from where she’s sitting on the toilet, hands gently caressing her own to inspect her blood-smattered knuckles. It’s a terrible excuse; how do you trip and punch a mirror?
But Draco doesn’t question it, and [Y/N] doesn’t have to tell him that she’d looked into the mirror and despised what she saw so much that she’d been overcome by an irrational anger and began to beat her fists against her own reflection until the glass splintered and the skin of her wrists did so along with it.
Draco tells her to wait, so she does, sitting in the cold bathroom by herself with blood dripping down her knuckles onto the floor until Draco comes back with a cloth in one hand and a pouch of healing ointments in the other. Once he’s cleaned up the mess on the floor, he kneels in front of her again and, quietly, gently, he begins to wipe the blood from her hands.
“Does it hurt?” Draco murmurs. His brows are drawn in the middle in a slight frown as he tries his hardest not to press too hard. He pauses and looks up at her, and his eyes are gentle, almost loving. Almost.
[Y/N] forces out a painful laugh. “Nothing I can’t handle.”
A smile tugs on the edges of Draco’s lips. “As expected.”
Then he quietly resumes nursing her wounds, and [Y/N] doesn’t realize that she has started crying until she tastes the tears on her lips. Draco notices but doesn’t say anything.
And because she is pathetically in love and she wants him to feel the same, when the cuts on her wrist have been bandaged and Draco is tucking away all of the tubes of ointment in his pouch, saying something about being more careful the next time (even though the both of them know fully well that her tripping was an excuse), [Y/N] tries again and says, “I love you.”
Draco freezes for nothing more than a split-second, but [Y/N] notices—her gaze is fixed on him intently, helplessly trying to gauge a reaction that part of her knows won’t come. But she wishes it would.
Her wishes are unheard. Draco nods, turns his head just a fraction of an inch to look at her out of the corner of his eye, and offers her a sad smile.
Almost.
—
“No, listen to me, Draco—I am TIRED!”
“And you don’t think I am?”
“I know you love her—Merlin, of course I know, I see it every time you look at me—but I’m asking you to try to love m—”
“You say it like it’s easy.”
There is a sob rattling in the back of her throat. [Y/N] swallows it back down and turns away from Draco like he hasn’t already seen the absolute mess of tears on her cheeks.
Draco stares out of the window, jaw taut and his fists clenched so tight at his sides his knuckles have gone a ghostly white.
“I knew we were getting married but I never expected much beyond a sealed contract and an agreement between our families—I never expected to fall in love with you but I did so here I am now asking you to do the same for me.”
A beat of silence. “You’re not her.”
Another swallowed sob. A brand new fissure in her heart that joins the thousands of others. “I’m sorry.”
More silence. Then: “I am too.”
And then Draco leaves first, because he always does.
—
Their fights don’t last long. Days follow and Draco and [Y/N] go about as they always do, pretending like the gaping void between them isn’t there. Whenever night comes, Draco will roll over and press a quiet kiss to the back of [Y/N]’s shoulders, snake one hand around her waist, and whisper I’m sorry, and [Y/N] will turn and drag her lips against his until Draco captures them in his own and they are stuck in that endless loop of want again.
Draco kisses the breath out of her and she kisses him back. Kisses him enough to make up for those few terrible minutes of anger she’d accidentally let loose days ago. Kisses him with love, with passion—with everything Draco doesn’t have.
When she gasps for air and Draco pulls away and trails his lips down her neck, leaving a trail of what feels like pure flame behind in his wake, she digs her nails into his shoulders and holds him in place. In a strained voice she says: “Look at me.”
He doesn’t. Draco kisses her throat and against her will she sucks in a desperate, shuddering breath, and the air sounds like Draco’s name. “Look at me, Draco,” she repeats, fingers pressing into his skin more insistently.
This time he stops and pries his lips away from her skin and hovers over her, eyes searching hers.
“When you’re with me,” she begins, eyes dark, breath coming quick, “I want to be the only one inside your head. I want you to look into my eyes and see only me.”
His grip on her waist tightens; her hands twist unsteadily in his hair, gaze clearing just a tiny bit as she says, “Please.”
And then he is dipping down to kiss her again, lips parted, breath rough. Somewhere in between their almost frantic kisses he whispers a response, and [Y/N] is much too lost in the feeling of his skin on hers but she thinks that Draco might be breathing words into her skin. They sound like apologies—sound like I’m sorry, sound like Astoria.
[Y/N] throws her head back as Draco brushes his lips over the curve of her collarbones and whispers something audible this time, and this time it sounds like I’ll try. Feels like hope. Feels like a door opening to something.
Feels, for the first time, something more than almost.
