Some Thoughts on the U.S.S. Discovery
I feel a little presumptuous saying I'm a "professional Star Trek ship artist," but I do at least have the perspective of attempting to be one. And the simple truth is that designing ships for Star Trek is hard... especially ships in Starfleet. Especially Starfleet ships that are supposed to be the "hero" of a TV show or a game or movie or whatever.
They need to be familiar (saucer and nacelles at the very least), but they also need to have their own special character. They need to say "I'm a Star Trek ship and I'm the hero!" but they also need to stand out among the other "hero" ships in that conspicuous pantheon.
There are dozens, maybe even hundreds of fan-created designs that are well done. They're aesthetically pleasing or logically arranged or have all the right details in all the right places. But so many of them lack a critical distinction when compared to whatever Enterprise inspired them. When you squint, you couldn't tell them apart from a Constitution or a Sovereign or a Galaxy.
And that's what it comes down to and why the original Enterprise is such an inspired design. Matt Jefferies didn't approach the problem of the original Enterprise as "How do I design a spaceship" - he approached it more like "How do I design a logo." I'm paraphrasing, but the crucial thing for him was that you could recognize the shape of the Enterprise while it was far away and moving fast. Just like a good logo, you could squint and still understand what you were looking at.
Ultimately, that's what the hero ship of a Star Trek show needs to be - not just a cool looking spaceship, but a logo, an icon, a brand that represents everything about its incarnation of the franchise.
A CBS representative said today during a press interview that the ship featured in the Star Trek: Discovery trailer is a work in progress, and I'm curious to see how it evolves as we get closer to January 2017. But already it has established itself with a distinctive silhouette and I imagine the final design is going to be pretty close to what we saw today. Ultimately I'm sure it'll find its way into our hearts; these ships always do.
But good luck to the artists working on her. That kind of responsibility is something I simultaneously do and do not envy!
