Oh, this fucking guy.
So apparently Andrew Blake (hereafter Andy), aka thanfiction, aka (now) CraftyCatDad, aka a whole bunch of other people over the decades, is back attempting to gain a(nother) following on social media.
Before I begin, a big thank you to @bemusedlybespectacled for identifying Andy as the author of this popular tweet thread, and spreading a community warning about him.
Unfortunately for everyone, Andy decided to post an (indirect) response. BemusedlyBespectacled and the truly incredible @theteablogger have already posted (excellent) discussions of his tweet thread. But his thread really pissed me off, and so I am going to do a breakdown of the some of the manipulation tactics he is using.
Unlike some other analysis posts I’ve made, I am not going to be looking at this thread in isolation – this is not a close reading within the four corners of our document. And that’s because, to give him credit, Andy is a good manipulator. I’ll be pointing out examples of this as I go through, but one of the tactics he is using in this thread is that a lot of it sounds reasonable outside the context of his history. While the extensive documentation of Andy’s history of abuse is both an independent good and useful to help warn people, the sheer amount of material can also make it difficult for a casual newcomer to know where to begin. This is particularly important when people point out behavior on Andy’s part that seems fine on the surface, but in context is part of a long history of a pattern of abusive and manipulative behavior.
This is a long post, but if you're inclined to scroll past without clicking the read more (or are like "Kaesa, what the fuck, I thought you didn't reblog callout posts and internet drama?"), I just want you to know that the tl;dr is this guy is super bad news and he is thus far the one exception to my no callout posts rule, because he has repeatedly caused people material harm in real life for decades, there is a paper trail, and his pattern of behavior is such that, if he really didn't mean to start two whole cults, he would have little to no internet presence. This is a guy who is legally prohibited from doing charity/not-for-profit work in the State of Oregon. It is emphatically not just internet drama.
The first paragraph of his long, weird Fanlore page is:
Andy Blake, a.k.a. Thanfiction, is a fanwriter and fanartist best known for his involvement in a number of high-profile fandom controversies. Blake is notorious for being at the center of incidents which include starting a cult in LOTR fandom, another cult in Harry Potter fandom, failed convention organizing, his many fraudulent identities and pseuds, faking the deaths of both his real and fabricated identities, and being witness to the homicide of his roommates/cult members.
Seconding OP's suggestion of Abbey/Kumquatwriter's blog posts about getting out of his cult.
















