Fanfics getting Archive.org’d
I got contacted by the person who I thought was posting my fics at Archive.org. They were cordial and apologized, and we talked. First, they thought I had been the one to post my fanfics on Archive.org, and they were just linking to it because of that. Second, it’s now clear that they weren’t the one who did repost my fic. So I’m publicly apologizing to them (probably best not to post their name again) here for that – especially since that person has apparently been hit with some harassment because of it. I always feel like I shouldn’t have to say this, but I’m old and keep forgetting that the internet has lost its gotdamn mind in the past few years, so: DON’T HARASS PEOPLE. JFC. I’m pissed off about this, too, but this person isn’t the one who put my fic up on another site – and even the one who did it doesn’t deserve death threats. Because that’s happening. But I should’ve expected that people would do this, and I didn’t because I was so freaked out and angry, so, sorry again. I’ve apologized to this person privately as well.
And to be clear, I’m well aware that some people want their work saved at Archive.org, and that a lot of fanfics get archived there – but I thought this was by the author’s choice. AO3 has two features that I (apparently mistakenly) thought would keep my fics from getting snapped by Archive.org: a little toggle in the preferences screen that allows readers to “Hide my work from search engines/indexing,” and the “Show works to AO3 users only” toggle in individual fic preferences. I’ve always had the former checked, but I’ve only occasionally locked my fics to the latter. I now know you need to do both to keep Archive.org trawlers off your fic.
I’m still thinking about creating a Discord for my fic instead. Probably won’t because I don’t really like Discord, but if I can’t keep my fic under my control on AO3 then I’ll need to do something else.
(For those who do not understand this, no, not all writers are grateful to have control of our work snatched out of our hands. Remember AO3 was created by and for writers who didn’t like our stuff being deleted or censored against our will… so I think it’s understandable that a lot of us would also not want our work copied or archived against our will, either. These are times when fic writers are getting shredded on Tiktok for likes, and our labors of love are training chatbots to make a profit. Being able to control our own work is pretty much the only defensive weapon we have.)
So again, to keep Archive.org trawlers off your fic (if that’s how it’s ended up there), you need to check the “Only Show Your Work To Registered Users” box in the post form, or the mass-editing form. If you find your work on Archive.org, you can (email link) request that it be taken down. Since I have hundreds of fics posted and only two seem to have ended up at Archive.org, I think some individual manually put those two there to preserve them, instead of just saving them to a private file or storage like most people do – but Archive.org is public, so doing this to a fic author without asking means taking their work from a nice protective, “domesticated” site like AO3 and releasing it into the wild, without warning. If the person who put up my fics is reading this… yeah, don’t do that. If people want their works archived in perpetuity, let them orphan them or put the fics up on Archive.org themselves.