Avatar

The world is quiet here

@snickeringsnicket / snickeringsnicket.tumblr.com

rachel (she/her). bmc. one time a famous comic book artist told me my life would make a good comic book so i guess i'm doin ok

The “don’t compare people to Hitler or call people nazis, it belittles the history” thing was meant for people who use the word ‘feminazi’ or call abortion ‘the baby holocaust’ or point out that ‘the nazis banned books’ when their favorite video game is cancelled.

When a right wing politician undermines basic human rights, criminalizes protestors and encourages violence against minorities, then yes, you can bring out the nazi comparisons.

@queeranarchism hey, are you Jewish or Rroma? Because if not, this really isn’t your call.

Even if you are Jewish, ask yourself why people will always go straight to nazi comparisons. A genocide that’s still internationally denied, doubted, downplayed? Why is it that people must comodify the suffering of the Jews and Rroma when more apt comparisons exist?

For example, the internment (hint hint) and forced separation of migrant children. Constant Auschwitz comparisons. Why, when America has its own guilty history to compare with? Not only does it recall the internment of Japanese Americans, but the stealing of indigenous children by America isn’t new. Residential schools, forced adoptions, intentional divorcing of these children from their cultures. Is that not a more apt comparison?

I do think some WWII comparisons are reasonable; for example, the rejection of Muslim refugees heavily resembles the rejection of the MS St. Louis, a ship full of Jewish refugees who were sent back to Nazi Europe.

But again, that was in America.

Not only does the immediate leap to nazi and holocaust comparisons comodify the suffering of two groups who are largely not afforded recognition for their plight, it allows America to pretend like it doesn’t have its own vile, racist, fascist history.

And that’s not something we can afford.