here is the issue i have with a big-tent, anybody-can-join trans “umbrella”:
i have no way to explain to someone who lives and presents entirely as their assigned sex, but identifies as nonbinary, that my being misgendered endangers my physical safety in a way that it doesn’t for them. that being misgendered doesn’t just ruin my day because it’s disrespectful and embarassing, but also because it reminds me of how vulnerable i am to actual physical violence. and being thus reminded 5+ times a day eats away at your mental health.
because anything i try to bring up, this person can (and did) counter with “well i’m trans too, i get misgendered too, i know how much it sucks, but you’re still just gonna have to deal with it.”
also, they have no difficulty in being seen as gay! they can enter gay spaces and lean on the gay community and find support and friendship there. i look and sound straight. i’m always going to be met with suspicion. most gay men (that i’ve met) are trans inclusive and wouldn’t run me off after they learn that i identify as a man, but that initial suspicion is always going to be there and as socially r*tarded as i am, i can still pick up on it.
i’m not going to tell this nonbinary person that they’re actually cis or anything like that, because that’s shitty, but i wish it were permissable to acknowledge how incredibly different our experiences are.










