Things YoI Fans/Ficcers Should Know About Skating (#27)
JUDGED (PART TWO): AN OVERVIEW OF PROGRAM COMPONENT SCORES (PCS) IN WHICH I EXPLAIN HOW KATSUKI YUURI IS A PRESENTATION GOD
I got a request from a lovely anon to break down Program Component Scores. If you know nothing about the judging system, you can check out my introduction to the ISU system here. And my introduction to Grade of Execution (GOE) here.
The Program Component Score is meant to replace the old “Presentation” or “Artistic” score that existed under the 6.0 system. It is there to make sure that the artistic side of the sport is paid attention to and that the sport doesn’t get too jump happy (which it’s totally doing anyway).
The Program Component Score is broken down into five categories or components. (I unashamedly stole these descriptions from the ISU website)
1. Skating Skills-which is the overall quality of the skating ability (e.g. balance, cleanness and sureness, flow, edges, multi directional skating, power)
2.Transition/Linking Footwork and Movement-which is the variety, difficulty and purposeful use of intricate footwork, positions, movements and holds that link all elements.
3. Performance/Execution- the physical and emotional involvement of the skater/couple as they deliver the intent of the music and composition (e.g. carriage, style, personality, variety, contrasts, projection).
4. Choreography/Composition- an intentionally developed and/or original arrangement of all types of movements according to the principles of musical phrase, space, pattern, and structure (e.g. idea, concept, unity, pattern, phrasing, originality, design)
5. Interpretation- is the personal, creative, and genuine translation of the rhythm, character and content of music to movement on ice.
To read, in detail, about what each component entails, here is an official memo from the USFSA which breaks each down.
During competition, each judge assigns a skater a score between 0.00 (you would basically have to not skate to get a zero)-10 (as the highest) in intervals of .25 points (so you can get a 5.25 as a score, but not a 6.15 or something).
There are nine judges on a panel, but the two outlying scores for each component are tossed (the highest score and the lowest score). The average of the scores is then factored through the same equation as the technical scores, so that, in theory, the presentation side of the program is of equal weight and importance to the score as the technical side (jumps, spins, etc.)
The technical scores are not capped, but the highest score a male competitor can get is 100 for his PCS (free program, 50 for the short) and the Ladies are capped at 80 (free program and 40 for the short). This is due to a difference in how the male scores are factored vs. the ladies, I believe.
The program component scores are much more open to judges interpretation than the technical elements and they can really help or hurt your score.
For instance, lets take a look at Yuuri’s score card. This is the example scorecard they use to explain judging in Episode 4…but I’m not sure what competition this is from cuz they gave him -2 GOEs on the triple axel but I’m pretty sure it’s from a short program.
Note: You can see a clean version of the score card here, on @yoimeta‘s blog. It’s a really cool blog a) because i’m mentioned (kidding) but b) there’s just a lot of fun thinking and great posts. You also get to listen to the soundtrack while you scroll! So check it out and show some love!
But regardless, he is a PCS GOD. Back off JJ, Yuuri is the King of the PSC and he’s not sorry. Look at these scores! Nothing below an 8.00 across the board, and he hasn’t even hit his stride int he show yet. He even gets a 9.75 for interpretation (which would probably get thrown out as an outlier) but that’s crazy. His total PCS for this program, which was not great, is less than eight points away from perfection.
Victor isn’t even kidding when he suggests they downgrade some of the quads in Yuuri’s program and count on the PCS early in the season…because our precious Katsudon would just fry the competition anyway if he skated clean. (Yes, that was a food pun. I am not ashamed).
TAKEAWAY FOR OUR BELOVED FIC AUTHORS: As far as I know, no one has maxed out the PCS score yet, but they have gotten close. (I’ve been looking into it, but my internet is being SO. SLOW. RIGHT NOW but the ISU records on the website don’t show the score breakdown, just the total. So, if you have info, you may politely drop it by the ask and I will updated this, if it is wrong, or until such time as my internet decides to move at a normal pace). So, if you wanted Yuuri to achieve a non-jump related thing…or oust Victor in an unconventional manner, he could literally skate clean and max out this bad boy AND make some history.