I'm not a huge fan of the MatPat Game Theory circle of videos, but I was watching one that flew by my radar. And MatPat engaged in soft Holocaust revisionism last week. I think that there needs to be an explanation of what that means, especially since no Gentiles in the comments seemed to notice what was going on, and an attempt to bring MatPat's attention to what he did.
So to start with, here's the video.
If you don't want to watch it, it's about a youtube series similar to Local 58 or the Gemini Catalogue about a world in which a bunch of meat monsters are taking over people's minds, there's a mega corporation run by the meat monsters which is keeping people complacent/making them vulnerable to the monsters, etc. It's a pretty standard matpat theory episode.
The important difference between this story and any other youtube horror series is the time setting. This story is set in the 1930s onward. There is one implicit reference to the Shoah (holocaust) at 6:22, where Mat says "the meat snake, which lived in the tunnels underneath Germany, became huge after eating *all the dead bodies from the war*" This story beat is brought back at the end of the video (18:00 onwards), where it is emphasized that the human meat that was fed to the monsters helped them grow and take over the world.
In the most generous interpretation I can muster, this theory is using the bodies of the people killed in the Holocaust to feed their imaginary alien monsters, already an artistic decision that I would call disrespectful to victims of the Holocaust.
But the reason I would call it soft Holocaust revisionism is because it seems to suggest that the motivations for the Holocaust in this world was the alien meat monsters mind control. This implies that 1) the Holocaust was not the product of human bigotry and fascistic "othering" of the marginalized, but of a Supernatural force that no human could have resisted and that 2) the people killed in the Holocaust were not killed because they were dehumanized and othered, but again, because some meat monster decided that they wanted to eat them.
This is not to say that MatPat or the creator of this series intended to do Holocaust revisionism. Both of these creators seem like tolerant, sensible people with respect towards history and knowledge. Which is why I think this should be brought to their attention. Making this sort of mistake in regards to history is in some ways understandable, especially given that the original creator seems to be a younger man, but it is a dangerous mistake to make nonetheless, especially when you have a platform as big as Film Theory.




















