Avatar

RP Trash Fire

@serfmc

Is it possible to have a good necromancer?

Avatar

Magic is as evil as its user. So yes, you can have a good necromancer, but how are you going to get the corpses for it?

Avatar

Plenty of bandits in the world.

One could argue that the level of disrespect for the dead inherent in necromancy makes it irreconcilably evil regardless of intention.

Depends on the culture involved. Sure that might be true for the traditional human society but what about drow? Or dragonborn? Perhaps to them the dead are just objects with the souls having moved on. Or another niche group of humans. Even if you do something considered Taboo if you have good intentions you still are good aligned even if you are considered problematic

This brought up something interesting to me if you homebrew away from the D&D ruleset on lifespans and look at ‘immortal’ races in classic fantasy, like the elves in Tolkien’s works.

So say your elves are similar to Tolkein elves, they don’t age or sicken like the mortal races. The only way they die is if they’re killed by violence. What would that do to a culture’s view of death? Would they even have an afterlife or would this world be the only realm of existence to them?

Would they see an elf’s death as unnatural and ‘evil’ and thus celebrate necromancy as a way to restore what ‘should’ be? Would they see necromancers as cosmic gardeners ensuring that life is protected?

PS Tolkein fans: I’m sure I’ve got a really shallow interpretation of his elves and there’s loads more to say there but I’m afraid I don’t have the knowledge to go deeper. Just thought the concept was interesting. Please don’t come after meeeee.

Avatar

What about a society built on the expectation that the dead will serve the living? The body is seen as just a vessel for the soul, and upon death all people are reanimated and set to work doing menial tasks and freeing up others to work less and relax more. Utopia built on a foundation of necronauts, maintaining an army of tireless, fearless workers that perform all the basic tasks of civilized life.

The Silver Swan, built by John Joseph Merlin and James Cox, 1773.

Source: Mechanical Marvels, Clockwork Dreams (BBC)

oh wow, the “water” is an illusion created by spinning glass rods.

wooooooooooah

Always reblog the clockwork swan

To prevent “the rise of the robots” only benefitting “a powerful and wealthy few”, the report suggests “putting the ownership and control of the robots in the hands of those who work with them,” he will say.
“The technology of the digital age should empower us both as workers and consumers, allowing us to co-operate on a scale in a way that wasn’t possible in the past,” he will add.
“And yet too often it has given rein to a more rapacious and exploitative form of capitalism.”
Mr Corbyn will criticise the wages and conditions offered by the likes of cab-hailing app Uber and food delivery service Deliveroo.
Such companies say their drivers and riders are self-employed and therefore can work when they want - and in return for that flexibility they do not get the same benefits as full-time staff.
Mr Corbyn will say: “Imagine an Uber run co-operatively by their drivers, collectively controlling their futures, agreeing their own pay and conditions, with profits shared or re-invested.
"The biggest obstacle to this is not technological, but a rigged economic system that favours wealth extractors not wealth creators.”

Me, as a DM, when I actually plan for a roleplaying session

Image
Image
Image

me criticizing fantasy settings in 2007: lmao none of this geography makes sense. and look at these names. this one has four apostrophes in it

me criticizing fantasy settings in 2017:  has no one…has no one considered the matter of fishing rights