I think the reason a lot of people hate on Evgenia is not because she wins, but because she keeps on breaking world records. The world records she broke are Yuna Kim's long program in Vancouver and Mao Asada's short program in WC are very rich in everything and are rendered as masterpieces. The two are also legends in the sport. Whereas, her programs that broke the records are just technically superb, but lacking the "it" factor that the previous WRs has shown.
Scores go up all the time, Base Value gets adjusted, rules and elements change.
While I can even agree about Zhenia’s programs lacking a bit on “wow” factor you usually link to world records, to hate on her ‘cause she gets higher scores than Mao or Yuna got years ago, it’s really childish.
It’s like hating on Jason Brown because his best score is higher than Plushenko.
Hate the way judges are giving out scores now, but why trash the skater?