Actual Request: “Hello. Can I please make a Klaus request where reader is human and friends with Damon and Stefan but one night her and Elena are in trouble and Damon& Stefan have to choose and they choose Elena but Klaus save reader. And once she’s healed Klaus says something cute like ‘Damon and Stefan will always choose Elena, but I will always choose you’?”
Requested by anon.
gif credit: not mine.
Ever since you met the Salvatore brothers, you always think that they are your guardian angels and protectors, your best friends. They were always there for you when you need a shoulder to cry on since Klaus had an interest in Caroline, not you.
You like Elena too, since she’s a nice friend to everyone but you can’t say that you like the entire thing between her and the Salvatores.
One night, when you and Elena coming back from a movie, some lunatic vampires decide to kidnap both of you.
You don’t know where you are but one of the lunatics tells you that the Salvatores need to decide who to save. Their precious doppleganger human Elena or you? Just a silly little high school girl who cries over boys?
You wait in there almost the whole night. They beat you up, give you some kind of medics you don’t even wanna know what they are. You mind is fuzzy and every inches of your body aches.
You hope them to come and get you but they never show up.
“Poor you,” says one of your kidnappers. “They chose to save their Elena. So I think you’re just gonna be our next appetizer.”
“I doubt that.” you hear this beautiful accent and the appetizer-loving-lunatic falls down.
“Klaus?” you ask surprised.
“Come on there love, don’t tell me you didn’t expect to see me at all.”
He carries you to his home, gives some of his blood and waits for you to be healed.
You feel better of course but you can’t get over being saved by Klaus. Because that means the Salvatore brothers saved Elena instead of you.
“Thank you, Klaus.” you whisper. “I thought I was gonna die for a second.”
He makes you cup of coffee and sits by your side.
“Those fools you call your friends, Damon and Stefan, would never choose you, love. And I couldn’t wait to kill some idiot vampires and see you again.”
“I thought you chose Caroline like they chose Elena.” you can’t help that make a sarcastic comment.
Klaus smiles slowly and puts his hand on your cheek.
“They will always choose Elena, love. But I will always choose you. In fact, there will be no other one to make a choice.”