I’m hearing people say that that it doesn’t add up that pearl and garnet are ashamed when we learned the Rose supposedly shattered pink diamond since she was framed so let’s look at some reasons why they’d react like this
1. Rose intentionally mislead them to think she had done it
- maybe Rose didn’t like to talk about it so they assumed the rumors were true
- (maybe she was a witness? Maybe she took the fame it got bc it got more info about the rebellion out?)
- maybe Rose lied about it to keep whoever shattered Pink diamond safe (maybe it’s someone on the inside? We still haven’t seen White Diamond.)
2. Pearl might have been involved with it (I’ve always assumed she belonged to pink or white diamond but we don’t know) and her and Rose both lied to keep Pearl safe, then she just got used to keeping the cover.
3. They knew no one would listen if they suggested a diamond shattered her
Idk how possible any of these are, but I’m just thinking of some ideas of what could’ve actually happened since it changes every other day.
I’d love to hear some other ideas!