All these Lucaya shippers (no i’m not censoring) think that Josh doesn’t know everything and can’t just waltz into the ski lodge acting like he knows everything (specifically Maya’s feelings).
need I remind you that Josh didn’t ‘waltz’ into anywhere, he was actually asked for his advice TWICE by Riley and Maya. If Evan can know so much about the clique six and their perception of love just from one conversation with Riley, imagine how much Josh knows at this point.
Are you guys forgetting that he is Cory’s brother??? Cory’s (and Topanga) have probably filled him in on A LOT that’s happened and Cory’s the least biased because he’s their teacher. Also Riley’s obviously given Josh her take on things beforehand, that’s why he knows of the triangle in the first place.
Stop acting like Josh doesn’t know anything just because we don’t see him a lot on the show, it can be assumed that his family members have told him things, and he actually hit the whole “you have the greatest capacity of love” speech on the nose. The writers wouldn’t have done this any other way.