thornton jones

2

Submission: Here is Ramin Karimloo as Raoul in the Final Lair.
I’m sure it’s Katie Knight-Adam as Christine and John Owen Jones as the Phantom. I could be wrong? It’s 2003 London production of Phantom of the Opera cast.

My comment: The first photo is actually Oliver Thornton, with Rachel Barrell and JOJ. It’s been circulating the web as Ramin Karimloo for some 10 years now, so I don’t blame the confusion on your part. But Ramin Karimloo never played opposite Rachel Barrell, which effectively rules him out :) 

The second one, however, is indeed JOJ, KKA and Ramin K, from the 2003-04 stage footage filmed for the 2004 movie.