After seeing Chapter 2, I am wondering more about how Bendy feels about being worshipped. Then again, he is, at this point, a demon on a rampage. Though I do also picture Bendy being curious about things (when not rampaging). So he likes offerings of new objects he can interact with (and break). Bacon soup and 'sheep' must get boring after awhile.
The way you worded that last sentence makes me think of Bendy having an entire closet of ‘sheep‘ that Sammy keeps giving him that he doesn’t know what to do with.