theory-coat

Questions I Want Answered

Who killed Ian?

Why was he killed?

Who Killed Garrett? 

Why was he killed?

Is Maya still alive? If not, who killed her?

What about “Maya Knew”? What did she know?

Who did Aria stab with that screw driver?

Was Melissa really the other Queen of Hearts?

Who was giving orders to Wilden?

Why did CeCe kill Wilden? 

Why did Jenna and Shana help Wilden when he was run over?

Who drugged Emily?

What happened the night Emily was drugged? Why was Jenna driving her around? Why was Holden with her? What’s with that stamp he had on his wrist? 

Who is Red Coat?

Who is Black Widow/Veil?

Who ran the car into Emily’s house? 

What are Noel’s secrets that Ali knows?

Who dug up “Ali’s” grave?

Where is Eddie Lamb, and what is his involvement? 

Why were Wren and Mona working together in Radley?

What is Wren’s involvement? 

What was the conversation between Ali and Peter when she was walking home alone that night in S5?

Who is Varjak?

Why would Varjak want to hurt Cyrus? 

What’s with all of the masks and the guy who makes them? Why was Melissa destroying all of them?

Why was Ali startled by the painting in the funeral home? It was also seen in Ravenswood and is connected to Ezra’s family.

What’s with the Apple references?

Who is Charles? 

Why was Mona helping Jason with his wound on his porch?

Who is keeping Tippy?

What is Grunwald’s involvement?

Who is Sara Harvey? Is she relevant?

Who is Bethany Young?

Why was Jessica involved with Bethany?

Who killed Jessica?

Why was she killed?

Who was Mona talking to at the hair salon when Hanna was getting her hair done?

Why did Jessica buy CeCe clothes if she couldn’t stand her?

Did Jessica know that Ali was alive? 

What happened to Aria’s pig puppet?

Will we see Meredith again? Is she involved?

Who was on the original A team? 

Why is Andrew sketch? What is his involvement? 

Why does A like to play with fire?

Who set Jason’s house on fire, Toby’s house, the lodge, locked Caleb in the furnace, etc….? 

What was the deal with the ice cream factory? 

Who is beach hottie?

Why was Ali hooking up with Holbrook?

Who is H? Why were they sending Aria on errands? 

Why was CeCe dressed as Ali “that night”? 

Why were Melissa and CeCe talking?

What happened to Lucas? What is his involvement? 

Why does A want Jenna dead?

Who was the other yellow dress for? 

How did Ali know about Bethany? Why did Bethany hate her?

What was the proof Mona found that made her think Ali was A before she “died”?

Who helped Mona in the video when she stagger her attack?

Who were the two people in Mona’s house on Thanksgiving?

Who kidnapped Mona? 

Why did Mona look dead? 

Who was dressed as the Black Swan?

Why did A start saying “kisses” and then stopped?

Who was Ezra yelling at in their car when Jake saw? 

Who tried to hurt Jake? And why?

Who tried to kill Mike? And Why?

Who is Sydney? Is she involved? 

Who’s body did Spencer find in the woods thinking it was Toby?

Is there any relevance to the body Hanna and Emily found in the morgue that had an Ali mask on? 

Who hit Ali with the rock?

Who was Jessica protecting by burying Ali? 

Who knocked out Toby in the woods? Why would they leave their lighter? 

Why did “Ali” take those pictures of Aria? Why hasn’t Ali’s photography skills/interest been brought up again? 

Who did Jason write a check for $50K for?

What information was he given? 

Who was the blonde girl that Dr. Palmer warned Toby about?

What really happened to Toby’s mom?

Who was staying in the DiLaurentis’ basement? Why did they drill holes in the floor?

Answered / Unanswered Questions:

Original questions by thebestplltheories (mostly) :)

  1. Who is Big “A”? CeCe Drake
  2. Who attempted to kill Alison? Cece Drake
  3. Why did Jessica cover for this person? Because it’s her daughter
  4. Who hit Bethany Young with the shovel? Mona Vanderwaal
  5. Why was Bethany Young killed? Mona thought it was Alison
  6. Why was Bethany Young at the DiLaurentis house that night? To kill Mrs.D
  7. Who attacked Mona in her house in 512? Cece Drake
  8. Who is the third Red Coat? Sara Harvey
  9. Who is the Black Widow? Sara Harvey
  10. What is Melissa’s secret? She buried Bethany Young
  11. What was Lucas’ true involvement with the ‘A’-Team? #Unanswered
  12. What really happened “that night”? Why did the ‘A’-Team dig up “Alison’s” body? #Unanswered
  13. Who killed Jessica DiLaurentis? #Unanswered
  14. Who killed Ian? He killed himself
  15. What were Melissa and CeCe talking about the night Alison disappeared? It wasn’t Cece
  16. And why was CeCe at the DiLaurentis house? To protect Alison from Bethany
  17. AND why was she wearing a similar outift to Alison? It wasn’t Cece
  18. What happened that day at Brookhaven with Alison and ‘A’? Did Alison meet Mona or did nobody show up? #Unanswered
  19. Who gave Alison that bloody lip? #Unanswered
  20. Who is the Beach Hottie? #Unanswered Maybe Wilden.
  21. Who was the Fragile Patient on the roof with Marion Cavanaugh? Bethany Young 
  22. Did they push her off of the roof on purpose? Yes
  23. What is ‘A’s motive? She felt like they were getting between her and Alison and that they were happy she was gone and then she became obsessed with them.
  24. What was the relationship between Bethany and Alison? Did Alison want her dead? Did she plan it? Her mom slept with her dad. No. No.
  25. Why was Jessica giving Bethany gifts? She wasn’t…they were for Cece
  26. Why did Jessica want Bethany to call her Aunt Jessie? Were they related? #Unanswered Possibly because her daughter and Beth were friends.
  27. Why was Bethany wearing the same outfit as Alison the night she was murdered? She stole it
  28. How did Alison’s ‘Jenna Thing’ bracelet get on Bethany’s body if she left it with Mona at the Lost Woods Resort? #Unanswered
  29. Who was Melissa speaking to on the phone the night Alison disappeared? #Unanswered
  30. Who was the shadowy figure hiding in Jason’s house? #Unanswered
  31. Whose bloody bandanges fell out out Jason’s trash? #Unanswered
  32. Where was Alison when she was thought to be dead? #Unanswered
  33. Who was taking pictures for Ezra’s book? #Unanswered
  34. Where are Wren’s loyalties? Who was he speaking to on the phone? #Unanswered
  35. And why was he drawing a picture of Red Coat? Is he somehow caught up in all this mess? #Unanswered
  36. Who was the fourth person who came to meet Jenna, Sydney and Mona in 5x05? 
  37. Who started the fire at the DiLaurentis house? Why were they trying to kill Jenna? Cece Drake and Yes
  38. Who tried to drown Jenna in 4x09? Why? Cece Drake
  39. Were Alison’s visits to Spencer and Aria real? #Unanswered
  40. Why was Alison wanting so much money before she disappeared? 
  41. Who pulled Aria, Emily and Mona out of the lodge fire? Sara Harvey
  42. Who was the blonde in the zoo in 4x20? Mona? Sara Harvey
  43. Why is Jenna so afraid of CeCe if she isn’t even ‘A’? Well she is A so..
  44. Who smashed Connor’s car? #
  45. What did Melissa mean when she said she’d been protecting Spencer “since before it started”? #Unanswered
  46. Why did Melissa form and alliance with Jenna and Shana? What was their aim? #Unanswered 
  47. What did Alison mean when she said “You know why I chose you” to Aria in 3x16? #Unanswered
  48. Does Alison really love Emily or is she just playing her?…
  49. Who took the photograph of Alison with Spencer’s shadow in the background the night she disappeared? #Unanswered
  50. Who took the photo of Alison and the Liars in 4x13 that was given to Holbrook? 
  51. Who was in the creepy zombie baby costume that attacked Alison in 2x13? #Unanswered
  52. Whose body did Spencer find in the woods in 3x21? A random guy
  53. Is Alison’s ghost story about the twins real? If so, who are the twins? #Unanswered 
  54. Why did one of them appear to Ashley Marin in 3x13? #Unanswered
  55. Who blew up the Cavanaugh house in 5x05? ‘A’ or somebody else? Cece Drake
  56. Where did Spencer leave the shovel after her encounter with Alison? How did it end up being used to kill Bethany?
  57. What was Jessica and Peter’s ‘agreement’?
  58. Why was Jessica giving CeCe clothes? Didn’t Jessica hate CeCe? It’s her daughter
  59. Who was in the car with Alison when she went to Hector’s studio? Why was Alison in such dire need of that money?
  60. How did Hanna get separated from the girls in the tunnel in 4x13?
  61. And what was up with those lights when Hanna was in the phonebooth? 
  62. What does Alison have on Noel Kahn to make him help her?
  63. What happened to Sara Harvey? She’s Alive 
  64. What was on page 5 of Alison’s autopsy report? 
  65. Whose blood was on Alison’s anklet? Hers or Bethany’s? 
  66. How well did Alison and Wilden know each other? 
  67. Was the story Mona told Spencer about her seeing Alison as Vivian in Brookhaven in 2x25 true? Or did she just make it up?
  68. If it was true, who was Alison watching? 
  69. Why did CeCe go back to Rosewood after she told somebody she was “sure as hell” not going back there? Because she became too obsessed with her “dolls”
  70. And why did was she eavesdropping on Ezra? Because she’s FREAKING A
  71. AND why was she wearing the black hoodie if she wasn’t ‘A’? Or is she secretly somehow involved? She’s A
  72. What were CeCe’s reasons for breaking up with Jason that she mentioned in Pretty Dirty Secrets? Something to do with Alison’s disappearance? Because he’s her brother 
  73. Who was the girl in the costume that came out of the changing room when Noel and Garrett were arguing in PDS? 
  74. Is Melissa good or bad? She seemed to want to push Aria and Garrett out of that train in 3x13.
  75. What was Red Coat’s plan for the Liars in 3x24? Why did she want them all at the lodge? To kill them but Shauna got in the way
  76. Who knocked Toby out in the woods in 3x24? Cece Drake
  77. Whose finger bones were sewn inside Spencer’s dress in 4x23? Or were they fake? 
  78. Is there still an ‘A’-Team or is it just one person acting alone? A and RC
  79. What’s up with the two pictures of Alison in her room? Vanity or twin?
  80. Is there a twin on the show? If there is, who?!
  81. Who was the girl behind the glass with Mona at the end of 5x03?
  82. How the hell is ‘A’ funding themself? Carasimmi Group
  83. What was going on between Mona and Shana in 4x12? 
  84. What happened between Ian and Melissa in Alison’s room after Jenna and Garrett left the night she disappeared? 
  85. Was it Alison or ‘A’ living under the DiLaurentis porch? Could go both ways
  86. What did Mona whisper to Lucas after she found the cow brain in her locker in 3x14? 
  87. What is on the NAT videos that could bring Alison’s family down? Probably something about Charles
  88. If CeCe knows who killed Bethany why hasn’t she told Alison as she claims it’s the same person after her? Or was CeCe bluffing? She was bluffing
  89. Why don’t Eddie Lamb and Wren like each other?
  90. What happened to Eddie Lamb? Why didn’t he turn up to meet Ezra?
  91. Who is the demon in Bethany’s drawings supposed to be? A?
  92. Why haven’t we seen Bethany Young’s face yet? We have and it’s irrelevant
  93. Who was Alison talking to through the personal ads in 5x13?
  94. Whose remains are in the barrel? some guy Cece got
  95. Whose drops of blood were on the floor of the storage unit? Alison’s
  96. Who sent Alison the note saying “Your friends will see you soon”?
  97. Is Holbrook good or bad? Irrelevant
  98. What is the history of Holbrook and Alison’s relationship? 
  99. Who was Bethany talking about on the tape? Alison or somebody else?
  100. Who was Mike leaving sweets for on that bridge? Mona 
  101. Why is Mike visiting Alison in jail? To see if she knew anything about Mona faking her death
  102. What is the ‘plan’ Bethany is talking about on the tape?
  103. Who is Varjak? Cece Drake
  104. What does the cryptic message the girls found in Mona’s room mean? Charles Dilaurentis
  105. Why was Andrew listening in on Veronica and Melissa’s phone call? Trying to find where the girls are at
  106. Why was Melissa calling Veronica?
  107. Who exactly is Charles DiLaurentis? Cece Drake
  108. Why was Mona looking dead in A’s trunk if she was alive? A drug
  109. How long has A been planning/building this dollhouse?
  110. Who put the note in Mona’s mirror? 
  111. Where’s Eddie?
  112. Where did CeCe  meet Sara?
  113. What happened to Tippi?
  1. Who is Charles DiLaurentis?
  2. Why did he harass the girls?
  3. Did they do something terrible?
  4. Did he really steal the game from Mona?
  5. Who is Uber -A? Is he the real bad guy?
  6. Who is Red Coat?
  7. How many Red Coat are they?
  8. Who is Black Widow?
  9. What really happened that night?
  10. Who hit Alison DiLaurentis?
  11. Who Jessica DiLaurentis was protecting? Charles? 
  12. Why Jessica Di Laurentis hides so much things to Kenneth?
  13. Is Kenneth taking revenge?
  14. What happened to Bethany Young?
  15. Why we never saw her face?
  16. Is she twins with someone else?
  17. Then who?
  18. Why she called Jessica DiLaurentis, his aunt?
  19. What happened to Marion Cavanaugh?
  20. What really happened to Maya St. Germain?
  21. Why Sara Harvey is shady? Why so many showers?!
  22. Who attacked her after her first job day?
  23. Why Aria Montgomery is shady?
  24. Why is she always representing with dolls and mirrors?
  25. Is she mentally ill?
  26. Why Noel Kahn is strange af too?
  27. WTF is going on with Wren Kingston?
  28. Is Rhys Matthews a cop?
  29. Is Wren Kingston a real doctor?
  30. Where is CeCe Drake?
  31. How is she connected to that story?
  32. Who killed Jessica DiLaurentis (if it’s not -A)?
  33. Is Freddy is an undercover for Charles?
  34. What about the Carissimi Group?
  35. Why Jason DiLaurentis is always away from Rosewood?
  36. How is big the -A team?
  37. Is there a team helping the girls?
  38. What is the link with Leslie Stone? What happened with her?
  39. Why everything is connecting to Radley?
  40. Why so many references to Varjak? Is he -A?
  41. Who killed Ian?
  42. Who pretended to kill Mona on the video at her home?
  43. Does Melissa hide more secrets than we know?
  44. Why we never saw Wren in London?
  45. Why Varjak number (727 242 7839) lead us to Sara Harvey? 
  46. Who’s Blood in Spencer’s bag (in London)?
  47. Why Edith Piaf songs? Why any relations to Paris?
  48. What happened at Melissa and Ian prom? Who was there?
  49. Who was the dancing girl Spencer saw at Radley?
  50. Why Hanna saw the twins so much?
  51. Who killed Garrett? -A?
  52. Why Jason is the only one alive in the N.A.T. Club?
  53. Was Alison pregnant or not?
  54. If yes, from who?
  55. Jenna and Lucas are together now? HOW?

But in Marlene King’s imagination, 42 minutes is enough. (Answers here!)

My thoughts on the PLL Summer finale.

“Summer of Answers” HAHAHA Summer of answers MY ASS.

First. Cece Drake is A. Is Charles Dilaurentis. Ok, I accept it. I liked her being A. It was unexpected by almost every PLL fan. So I liked to be a shocking reveal. But after that, EVERYTHING IS A MESS.

Before my thoughts, here you have the ages of the liars and Cece in the show.

The age gap between Alison and Cece is 7 years. So explain how this is Jason, Charles/Cece and Ali.

It’s IMPOSSIBLE. That girl can’t be 7 years younger that the kid in the middle. There’s only two possible things here: 1) That girl is Bethany or 2) The writers made a huge mistake.

When they found Bethany’s body, the cops said she was 18 when she died. So she was 18 in 2009. That’s a 3 years gap between her and Cece. Tell me how Bethany looks older than Charles/Cece in the flashbacks when she was younger. Another mistake, Marlene.

AND HERE GOES THE BIGGEST MISTAKE!!!

If the episode “The First Secret” Toby said his mother died in 2007. 2007!!
Cece was 19 and Bethany 17. THIS KIDS LOOK LIKE 19 AND 17??

So in the story Cece tells, Marion Cavanaugh died when she was a kid. Toby and Alison must had like 5-7, more or less. OKAY? SO EXPLAIN HOW MARION IS AT HER HOUSE WITH HER TEENAGER SON AND HIS TEENAGER FRIEND!

With that story I felt so dissapointed because I think the writers don’t pay attention to their own show.

Let’s move with the motive of Cece/Charles torturing the girls.

Cece really tortured them for three years because they were friends of Ali? Because the felt “”good”” when she was “dead”? Didn’t Cece see all the things the girls did to protect Ali from A, from her? The girls cared a lot about Ali when they found she was alive. They did everything to protect her and make her feel save enough to come back to Rosewood. It doesn’t make any sense.

Ok, she entered Radley when she was 8-9 (the baby Alison wasn’t more than 1 and half) and Cece said the next 7 years she was alone. So it makes an age of 15/16. Charles died at 16 so that makes sense. YAY.

Twelve. Alison had 5. This little girls is not 5. She looks like 7/8. 

____

C’mon Mona. You’re the smartest one, you knew you didn’t kill Alison because you were the one who helped her to fake her death. You’d must known you hit/killed another girl. Another mistake?

Sure he knew, then why he could sabotage Aria’s exhibition and why he showed up at Dilaurentis’ looking for Kenneth?

ARE YOU KIDDING ME?

ARE YOU FUCKING KIDDING ME??
That was the thing that disappointed me the most. HOW SUCH IMPORTANT AND MYSTERIOUS CHARACTERS WE’VE BEEN THEORIZING ABOUT IS THE SAME FUCKING CHARACTER WE’VE SEEN IN 10 EPISODES AND HAS BEEN IN THE SHOWER 5 OF THEM AND FLIRTING WITH EMILY THE OTHER 5???? I’M SO MAD WITH THAT.

THANK YOU EMILY. THANK YOU. WE ARE ALL EMILY. 

C R Y I N G

MORE TEARS

WHAAAAAAAT??? SHE IS MARRIED??? OR SHE CHANGED HER LAST NAME?

WHAT WHO??? WHOS COMING??? OH ALISON YOU LOOK STUNNING BUT WHO’S AFTER YOU NOW???

WHY? WHAT’S HAPPENING?? HANNA STUNNING TOO.

WHO’S HERE?? WHO?? HE??? DON’T YOU DARE TO LEAVE ME LIKE THAT UNTIL JANUARY FUCKING 2016.DON’T.

Another Plot Hole or Lie CeCe Told!

Do you guys remember when Emily met CeCe while she was packing up her stuff to leave Rosewood? Emily confronted her about the night Alison disappeared. She asked why she was meeting Melissa Hastings in Alison’s backyard.

So this is what CeCe had to say and I quote: 
“Ali called. She was freaking out about some videos. Everyone wanted them. Spencer’s big sister more than anyone. When I showed up she begged me to talk to Ali so I did. Then Ali left to go get them. Next day she was missing.”

So let me get this straight. She literally admitted that she was there that night meeting Melissa. So it is true what Jason told us.

But in 6x10 CeCe told Alison that he didn’t see her that night. 

And I quote: “He saw Bethany or he saw you. He didn’t see me.”

How come that Jason saw her and CeCe admitted earlier that she met with Melissa? And now she suddenly says no one saw her?
To me that sounds like a plot hole. If not.. why would she lie about it? And why did she tell Emily that story. Personally I believe that Jason saw her. The story sounds truthful. 

EDIT: And by the way.. people who say that she simply lied about it. Then how did she immediately know that Jason saw her with MELISSA that night. Emily just asked her IF she was in Ali’s backyard that night. Not if she met with Melissa.. suspicious. 

people who would have been a better redcoat than sara harvey:
  • pepe the dog
  • jason dilaurentis
  • the weird psychic lady
  • the entire cast of ravenswood
  • hanna’s stepsister from season one
  • emily’s boyfriend in season one
  • mike montgomery
  • spencer’s dad
  • toby’s mom
  • toby
  • that pilot dude who flew alison around
  • ezra’s little brother
  • ezra’s child
  • leslie knope from parks and recreation
  • anyone but sara harvey
  • the dude that made masks from alison’s face
  • the waitress from that called toby “pretty eyes”
  • aria’s babysitter from childhood
  • holden
  • jake the martial arts instructor
  • every member of the bee gees
  • alison’s friend from camp that won an archery award that alison made her pretend she had won
  • holly golightly from breakfast at tiffany’s
  • f. scott fitzgerald himself
  • tippi the bird
  • sorority sister #4 from that sorority house they went to that one time
Evolution of A
  • Season 1: threatens to tell the girls parents about the bad things they do.
  • Season 2: continues to threaten with messages and small gifts.
  • Season 3: guess whos back? Back again. Shadys back, tell a friend.
  • Season 4: gonna set these girls on firrreee.
  • Season 5: kidnaps the girls and tortures them.
  • Season 6: I came out to throw a birthday party and I'm feeling quite attacked right now.