Characters: Dean Winchester, Little Susie (OC), Sam Winchester, Y/N L/N (Reader)
Pairing: Dean x Reader
Summary: Dean has a secret, one that kills him every year. One night, he decides to confront it, sending himself back into memory lane as he drives to his destination. It’s one thing to feel guilt, but to keep it from the one person he cared about just as much as Little Susie? Time would tell…
Word Count: 3k-ish
Warnings: Angst, Light Fluff, Mention of a Character Death
Author’s Note: Hey guys! This is my entry for @hasta-impalasta‘s 1k Celebration! I had the song “Concrete Angel” by Martina McBride. I hope you guys like it! After debating a lot of approaches, this one was the one that drove me to write all of this lol I hope you guys like it and PLEASE! Feedback is greatly appreciated!! <3
I watched Y/N’s sleeping form one final time before I grabbed the keys off the table and quietly opened the door, careful not to wake both her and Sam up. It was a one-man-mission. They didn’t need to tag along. Not tonight.
Her name was Susie. Little Susie, I used to call her. I remember when Dad used to drop Sammy and I off at Miss Lovett’s a few days out of the week while he went on a case. We used to be playing out in the front yard and every afternoon, the school bus would drop Little Susie off right in front of her house. And every day, she would turn around and wave at us, a huge smile on her face.
The afternoon sun glared down at Sammy and I as we watched with a smile as the school bus came to a screeching halt across the street. After a few seconds, it drove away, leaving behind Susie Alcott, bright red hair and the most beautiful blue eyes I’d ever seen. She would turn around and wave at us, her toothy grin so clear even from that distance.
I liked Susie.
I waited until Sammy was asleep before sneaking out of the window in the bedroom he and I shared. I wasted no time in running across the street, picking up stray rocks in the process. Once I reached her window, I bit my lip and aimed for the wood next to it and tossed a rock at it, hoping to get her attention if she was awake.