So Here's what happened
I started laying D&D a little while ago and during my second session our party: 2 warriors, 1 bard, 1 sorcerer, 1 rogue and a barbarian agree to take this cursed coffin that held a Lich spirit inside down into an ancient crypt. Turns out there was a large labyrinth beneath the graveyard and the walls were made of doppelgängers. One of the warriors gets taken and is pulled up to the ceiling and is surrounded by doppelgängers that take on her appearance.
Rogue: I want to climb up and get her down from the ceiling.
DM: Role for perception and athletics.
(Roles an 18 and a 23)
DM: Okay, you easily scale the wall of doppelgängers and successfully grab the real one. Now both of you are stuck to the ceiling.
Female Warrior: I want to try to break free.
DM: Strength check.
DM: You successfully break free from their grasp and the two of you are now falling.
Male warrior (Me): I would like to try to catch them.
DM: role a strength and athletics for each of them.
(For the rogue I roll a 16 and a 17.)
DM: Okay you manage to grab the rogue’s cloak and pull him up on the wall of the labyrinth. Take two damage. What about the warrior?
Me: 14 and a natural 1!
DM: (Face palms and lets out a groan) You successfully grab the warrior as she’s falling but the weight of her heavy plated armor is too much for you and rips your arm from it’s socket.
DM: However the rogue that just lit a torch cauterizes it.
Shenanigans continue on until the party meets up again. Rogue and sorcerer are trying to lift the heavy stone coffin that has the lich’s soul.
Sorcerer: Can someone give me a hand with this?
Me: I throw my arm at him and say: “Just be sure to give it back when you’re done with it.”
(DM Stares at me)
We continue through the crypt as we avoid several traps and ambushes by the undead.
Rogue: Is the reward even worth it?
Female warrior: This quest is gonna cost us an arm and a leg.
Me: I’m already halfway there.
DM: Why? Why are you like this?