Loved your new theory, you were so spot on! I just have one question, why did you guess that pastor Ted was Charlotte's father? Was there I clue that I missed?
Nick actually sent me a photo that I guess was from the promo sets they usually release before the episodes, one had a picture with Ted and Hanna sitting down- Ted had a photo in his hands. it looked to be him and a young blonde teen boy so I assumed it was Charlotte. That’s all really!