Everything’s Fine Pt. 2 (Poly!Hamilsquad x Reader)
Warnings/Triggers: Cursing, Angst? IDK
Time Period: Modern
Notes: Nne :P
Requested: An Anon asked for part 2, so here you go!
Hope you enjoy!
If there’s a warning I need to add, please let me know! I want you to feel safe and comfortable reading my stories! Thanks!
It had been a month. One month of seeing them in the halls of the apartment, or at the store. But you had never spoken. Not since the day on the roof.
You had spent the last month trying to get your mind of them. You had jumped from different one night stands at clubs, none of which helped. You were still up at night, thinking about them. How can you make that feeling just vanish?
You sat with your head on Eliza’s lap as she stroked your hair.
“Y/N, you can’t daydream about them forever. You need to talk to them!” She coaxed, finally sitting you up.
“Eliza! Of course I want to but, Alex…” You said, suddenly finding the floor interesting.
Eliza sighed, “I know. How about we get some cupcakes? There’s a bakery down the street and I know Angelica and Peggy would love to come!” She smiled at you, lifting your chin up to meet her eyes.
You smiled, you did love the bakery. They had the best cookies in existence. Maybe just an hour or two. Maybe that’d help get your mind of them.
How wrong you were. As you got out of Angelica’s car, you heard Peggy’s voice from behind you.
“Oh boy, don’t look now Y/N.” She grabbed your shoulder, gesturing to behind her.
You slightly spun your head, hoping to catch a glimpse of whatever was distracting her. Although you couldn’t get a view without turning around, a certain french accent made it clear who was there.
“Y/N? Why are you here mon amour?” He said, being the first to spot you. You tensed up at his nickname for you. His voice hadn’t distracted the rest of the group from talking, however. Alex was still going on about something or other.
“Laf. Hey. We were going to get some cookies or something.” You said, noticing his expression sadden a bit.
“Oh, I see. We were walking to the coffee shop. You should join us if you have time. You may not want to, but we miss you mon chaton.” He smiled a bit, his sleeve getting tugged by John as they walked away. You watched them leave and figured that he must have told the boys. Alex froze for a second, before whipping his head around and staring at you.
You tried to avoid meeting his eyes. You couldn’t talk to him. You were the one that left, you chose this. So why did you regret every second of it?
“Wait! Maybe we should join you!” Peggy said. You loved the girl, but this was one time where you just wanted to go home.
Lafayette whipped around, staring at her with a smile. He waved your group over as you stayed in the back and groaned.
Peggy ran after the boys, followed by a rather energetic Eliza. Angelica stayed with you for a minute.
“If they try anything, I will bitch slap everyone one of them.” Said she, a smirk on her face. This girl always knew what to say.
You and Angelica had trailed behind the group. The occasional glance from John told you to join the others, but you could face Alex. Was that what he really thought?
He kept your eyes on you feet before noticing that Angelica had stopped beside you. You looked up to see the cafe in front of you. Angelica dragged you through the doors, settling at a table in the corner.
After what seemed like an eternity, Eliza dragged her sisters off to get drinks for the group. Half of you thanked her but the other half was furious that they left you alone.
What are you doing here? This won’t work. Just go home.
“You alright?” John’s voice took you straight out of your thoughts as he looked at you, Herc beside him. You stared into his eyes for a few seconds, before realizing what you were doing. You looked at all the boys, they all looked at you with the same concerned look. Except Alex. You looked at him for what felt like forever, before finally looking down.
“Y/N, we’re sorry.”
Tears had gathered up in his eyes already, threatening to spill. The sight almost made you cry too.
“I didn’t mean it. I love you and I-I said some fucking stupid things and I understand if you hate me, but please don’t be mad at everyone else? They tried to stop me, but I was too stubborn, I—” You cut him off with your giggles.
“What? Did I do something wrong Y/N?” He looked at you, the tears finally spilling down his cheeks as he desperately reached for your hand.
“No, I’m not mad. It was my fault too. I’m sorry.” You didn’t notice the tears on your cheek until Laf reached over and wiped them off your face.
John wrapped his arms around you, staining your shirt with his tears. The other people in the cafe probably thought you were insane, but at that point you didn’t care. You all had tears pouring down your faces. A month without each other really does some damage.
“Well, well, well. Look what we have here.” Angelica said, taking her seat at the end of the table. “Back together finally?” She said, nudging your shoulder. You nodded, leaning into John.
You almost jumped out of your seat when you heard a squeal.
Eliza had placed the coffee cups down and hugged Peggy (Who looked rather surprised).
“You know what this means?!” She said, Peggy trying to calm her down. “We can all have a movie night!” She screeched, this time at a slightly lower volume than previously.
You all laughed, Alex looked across the table to you, a sad smile gracing his face. You met his eyes with a cheery smile, instantly comforting you both.