similar beauty marks

Spencer Hastings Could Be A Twin

This is a bit outrageous and probably a bit exaggerated but we hope to have found enough evidence to make this theory plausible. Ever since Sasha Pieterse spilled the beans about Ali not having a twin but someone else could, we’ve been pulling each others hair trying to come up with a possible character. Well, we’ve added Spencer Hastings to our list and below you’ll find evidence that we’ve gathered on the pretty little liar.

Is Spencer Hastings one of the twins from Ali’s story …

We’ve been so hung up on the blonde hair and never noticed that the twins from Ali’s story have different beauty marks. In Ali’s story, the twin with the beauty mark on her right cheek killed the twin with the two beauty marks on her left cheek. We noticed one character who have similar beauty marks on their left cheek and that would be Spencer Hastings.

We considered Spencer a long time ago but excluded her because she doesn’t have blonde hair. What if the blonde hair is just a misinterpretation of the story? Perhaps, when the story was told over and over again, somewhere down the line the twins hair color was changed by the person telling the story. Also, if the hair was misinterpreted than there’s a strong possibility that the twin that was murdered was misinterpreted as well.

Twin that was murdered probably misinterpreted …

In the Halloween episode 3.13 ‘This is a Dark Ride’, we noticed that the twin that visited Ashley Marin was the twin with the beauty mark on her right cheek. In Ali’s story, the twin with the beauty mark on her right cheek was the murderer but her ghost visited Ashley Marin which lead us to believe that the story Ali told was not correct. Therefore, the twin who has two beauty marks murdered the twin with the one beauty mark which leaves the twin with two beauty marks on her left cheek, and we are thinking that that twin is Spencer Hastings. (This is crazy, right?)

.Spencer’s dress in the PLL Season 1 promo …

We posted not long ago that the dress Spencer is wearing on the Season 1 promo poster is the same dress that the deceased is wearing in the casket in the intro. We know there were budget shortages while making the first season but is this a coincidence, or could this be a clue that Spencer is in fact a twin and her twin (beauty mark on right cheek) is the one that is in Ali’s casket and not this Sara Harvey person? Ali is alive and there has to be someone in her casket besides this unknown Sara Harvey person, who we believe was created to throw us off.

Blunt force trauma to the head …

The teen that is presumed to be Ali was hit with a curved object. There are apparently two objects that were found that could have been the murder weapon, a field hockey stick and a shovel. The Rosewood police believed the shovel was the weapon that was used to murder Alison DiLaurentis (who isn’t dead) but Peter Hastings was determined to get rid of the field hockey stick that Toby found buried in their yard (2.07). We are curious as to how the field hockey stick got there when Alison DiLaurentis was the last person seen with the stick but Spencer Hastings was the first liar awake the night of Alison’s disappearance. We wonder if this was the night that Spencer killed her twin (or thought she killed her twin) and the story that Ali told Hanna was a foreshadowing of what actually happened.

The Hastings has secrets … 

It is possible that Spencer could have done things that summer and don’t remember and her parents and Melissa have been keeping it a secret from her. Wouldn’t it be a huge shock if Spencer Hastings was a twin? We have always wondered why Mona wanted Spencer to get admitted to Radley, was Spencer’s twin a patient there once upon a time? Mrs. Hastings didn’t seem too concerned when Spencer presented the file about Wilden to her in 4.08, we wonder if the Hastings paid Wilden off because their daughter was a patient their at the time and they wanted to keep that a secret. If Spencer’s twin was a patient in Radley during the time Marion Cavanaugh was there, could this twin be the one that murdered Marion and the Hastings paid Wilden off to cover everything up. Ashley Marin told Ella Montgomery in 2.07 that “Peter Hastings, who never met a problem he couldn’t buy off.” You have to wonder if the Hastings are hiding something.

Ali Ali Oxen Free

We posted not long ago about Ali Ali Oxen Free, a saying that Spencer claimed she and Melissa played all the time and it was her favorite game. What if Spencer played this game with her twin not Melissa, but she remembers Melissa as her only sister because that’s what her parents fed her for the past years.

Black Veil …

Our curiosity is running wild with this one so we are going to end this now, but hope to add to it as more information come in the 4B half.

Other Spencer Hastings theories: