shin getter vs neo getter

grand-rizer  asked:

Any certain mecha anime/manga you DON'T recommend?

You mean besides the original GoLion? (Worth watching only if you REALLY want to see what got censored in Voltron, because it’s essentially a lesser version of the Robot Romance Trilogy).

I tend to believe that a lot of stuff I dislike may have a fanbase, but personally, my two biggest dislikes from the mecha genre recently are Code Geass and Gundam: Recongusita in G. There’s plenty of older dreck like Great Dangaioh (an atrocious follow up to the cult classic OVA) and Getter Robo Go (which has nothing to do with the kickass manga, and the animation studio later produced Shin Getter Robo vs Neo Getter Robo as an apology/proper use of the characters) but those two are the most recent ones.

Geass has a problem with its characterization that despite cool ideas, there’s a bizarre sheen of cultural bias and fear of gaijin permeating the whole thing. It’s not helped by then writers own frustration with being forced to repeat plot lines between seasons, to the point where when you do get to the finale, it feels “meh.” There are some beautifully done action sequences but the feel ultimately too few. This is a show where everyone’s opinion varies, so my advice is to see if you can get through the school focused filler stuff or want to tap out early.

Reconguista is just confusing, and the director, the legendary Tomino (creator of the Gundam franchise) admitted to such after it finished. If I don’t know what’s going on or the characters connection to the central conflict, why am I supposed to care? And all this sandwiched between Gundam Thunderbolt, Gundam Unicorn, and Build Fighters. Even the show about models was better (but that show is surprisingly well done). Put simply, even confusing shows eventually reach their point. Reconguista never does.

To be fair, I haven’t seen Cross Ange or Valvrave the Liberator (not to be confused with Gargantia on the Verduous Planet, which is good but sadly incomplete) yet, which are both supposed to be in a league of their own when it comes to awfulness.

Scope Dogg’s Mecha Showcase: Getter Robo: Armageddon

This is part of a series of reviews I plan on doing on various mecha franchises. The only rule is that I’m not touching the three franchises I think are the most well known (Gurren Lagann, Evangelion, Gundam) in an effort to spread the love towards some series that I feel fly somewhat under the radar for non-mecha fans. Any spoilers will only be very minor and will typically only concern the very beginning of the story.

Why you should watch it, in brief:

A standalone, alternate-universe adaptation of one of the best chapters of a truly classic super robot franchise. Flawed storytelling fails to put a damper on its striking presentation, or it’s stylish and brutal action scenes that remain true to what the Getter Robo universe is all about.

The setting:

Humanity came under threat from an alien menace known only as The Invaders, who struck upon the moon and menaced Earth itself. However, they were stopped by the Getter Robo, the creation of the genius scientist Dr. Saotome, and piloted by three heroes - Nagare Ryoma, Jin Hayato, and Tomoe Musashi. While the invader threat seemed to be defeated, not all was well. Shortly after, Dr Saotome was murdered, and Hayato framed Ryoma for it, for reasons unknown. Now, things take another mysterious turn, as Dr. Saotome seems to have risen from his grave, and appears to the world once more, this time with sinister motives in mind, as well as a menacing new creation - a supremely powerful Getter machine called Shin Dragon. As humanity scrambles to stop him, even releasing Ryoma from jail in order to attack Shin Dragon, The Invaders appear once more to threaten humanity. The events that are about to transpire will push humanity to the brink of extinction, and Getter pilots both new and old must take up a desperate struggle to rescue mankind.

Why you should watch it, in full:

Despite being relatively unknown outside of Japan, Getter Robo is one of the most venerable franchises in the entire mecha genre. The series is sometimes mistakenly attributed to Go Nagai of Mazinger Z fame, and while uncle Go did have some input on the series, it’s ultimately the brainchild of his close friend Ken Ishikawa, who created Getter in the form of a long-running and very well-regarded manga series, sadly cut short by Ishikawa’s death in 2006. Getter’s creation was roughly contemporaneous with that of Mazinger, but it stands apart in several ways. The most obvious is the overall tone of the work - while early Mazinger is typically fairly upbeat and with an unambiguously heroic protagonist and ridiculous villains, Getter is much, much more hard-edged, with borderline psychotic “heroes”, scenes featuring some pretty nasty and intense violence, including the brutal deaths both of likable protagonists and innocent bystanders, and enemies that are sometimes silly but sometimes nightmarish, who usually have genocidal aims in mind. If Mazinger is the father of the mecha genre, Getter is kind of like it’s creepy, slightly unhinged uncle. Of course, that’s not to say that Getter is any less influential - it introduced so many common tropes into the mecha genre that they’re hard to count. Consider what people typically like about Gurren Lagann, for instance. Hot blooded combinations? Getter invented it. Glowing green energy that’s a manifestation of the pilot’s fighting spirit? You might be talking about Spiral Power, but you could just as easily be talking about Getter Rays. What about Gurren Lagann’s most distinctive trademark, the giant drills? Well, those were Jin Hayato and Getter 2′s signature weapon long before Simon, Kamina and the gang got their hands on them. I could go on and on.

While the Getter Robo manga saga is uniformly revered, it’s had a rockier road when it comes to being adapted to animation. There was a long-running Getter Robo anime in the 70s, but much like its competition of the time it’s aged poorly, and arguably didn’t capture the real hard edge that the franchise is famed for. The later anime adaptation of Getter Robo Go, one of the manga’s most loved installments, is universally reviled for more or less the same reason. In more modern times, there are three good animated Getter productions, each taking place in their own continuity. I had to weigh up which one I was going to recommend, because they all have their own pros and cons. There was 2007′s New Getter Robo, which is a mini-reboot of the original story, with solid art direction and strong characterisation, but an odd storyline that I really didn’t care for. There was also Shin Getter Robo vs. Neo Getter Robo, which is a fairly loose adaptation of Getter Robo Go spliced in with plot elements from the original installment of the manga. That’s a good but slightly silly outing that I feel is trumped by the production I’m about to recommend, Getter Robo Armageddon. Opinions of Armageddon vary quite wildly, and while I’m a big fan of it for many reasons, I also recognise it’s far from perfect. However, it’s flaws are trumped by it’s truly memorable presentation, and while it’s an alternate-universe work I feel like it’s the series that captures the spirit of the source material the best. More details after the break.

Keep reading


 真ゲッターロボ対ネオゲッターロボ STORM