Okay, it’s time to talk about Sarah Smiles.
I’m going to share my feelings on this song. It was in Vices and Virtues, meaning it was a while after the song. It was supposedly a song that Brendon wrote to ask Sarah out, but it REALLY does NOT sound like a love song. Case in point: “You fooled me once with your eyes now, honey, you fooled me twice with your lies”. That is not the lyrics of a love song.
Second, Brendon sounds SO FUCKING ANGRY through the whole song, with instrumentals to match. They’re loud, angry, and all-out bitter. Especially at the peak of the song: “Sarah smiles like Sarah doesn’t CARE.” If you listen to that part, he accentuates the “care”, making him sound very mad.
I encourage you to listen and pay attention to this.

Signs as Panic!At The Disco Song’s

Aries-This Is Gospel
Taurus-New Perspective
Gemini-Don’t Threaten Me With A Good Time
Cancer-Sarah Smiles
Leo-Emperor’s New Clothes
Virgo-Build God,Then We’ll Talk
Libra-I Write Sins Not Tragedies
Scorpio-Crazy=Genius
Sagittarius-LA Devotee
Capricorn-Northern Downpour
Aquarius-Vegas Lights

Pisces-House Of Memories

The Signs as ‘Vices & Virtues’ Songs

Aries: Let’s Kill Tonight

Taurus: The Ballad of Mona Lisa

Gemini: Turn Off the Lights

Cancer: Memories

Leo: Hurricane

Virgo: Ready to Go (Get Me Out of My Mind)

Libra: Always

Scorpio: Nearly Witches (Ever Since We Met…)

Sagittarius: The Calendar

Capricorn: Kaleidoscope Eyes

Aquarius: Sarah Smiles

Pisces: Trade Mistakes