Not only is AC III my favorite but I keep finding myself coming back to it. Not replaying mind you, but going back to read the historical data entries and free-running across the cities and wandering the Frontier. I love AC III for how great it was presented as an intro into a new arc of the series. AC III does have its faults, yes, but personally I believe that the American Revolution was an AWESOME setting for the game even though it may not have been presented in the best way.
image from madeinmasyaf
[continued below -N]