After a hunt gone wrong, Y/N Winchester, the 17 year old half-sister of Sam and Dean Winchester, her older brothers, and Castiel are transported to Riverdale, a town in a different universe. While Sam, Dean, and Castiel attempt to find a way back home, Y/N struggles to fit in in the community of Riverdale. In a universe with no monsters to worry about, there’s so many questions that need answering.
Can she ever try to be normal after hunting for all of her life? Who’s the good-looking, mystical teen with the beanie who’s always at that diner? And will anyone discover that secret she’s been hiding for the last year and a half?
“Why’s everyone staring at us?” Sam asked as the four of you walked through the town of Riverdale.
You looked around and saw that people indeed were staring at you guys. You looked down at your outfit of a black tank top, plaid jacket, and jeans which were ripped a bit at the knees.
“They’re staring at us? We should be staring at them. They look like a modern version of the fifties.” he said.
“Dean.” Castiel chastised.
“What?” Dean asked. “They do.”
You smiled and shook your head, continuing your walk.
“Hey,” Sam said stopping.
The rest of you stopped, turning to him as he nodded to something behind of you. You faced forward again, seeing a small diner with sign above it.
““Pop’s,”” he said. “Guess that’s where we’re eating.”
“I’ve had worse.” you said as the four of you walked the short distance to the diner in silence.
“Alright,” Dean said as everyone stopped outside the diner.
“Sam, Cas, and I’ll go to that gas station next door and ask anyone if there’s a motel close by. Y/N, you go in the diner and find us a booth.”
“Yeah, sure,” you said. “See you in a few.”
The boys went in the opposite direction as you walked up the stairs to Pop’s. The bell jingled as you opened the front door and you breathed in the familiar scent of a diner. You walked over the counter to where a man was cleaning the tabletop off.
“Can I help you?” he asked, looking up.
You looked up at the man across the counter, presumably Pop.
“Uh, yeah, can I have four waters to start, please?”
“Thanks.” you muttered as Pop got started on your order. You took a seat in a booth closest to the door, unaware of the four people across the diner who had been watching you the entire time.
“Well, I for one am excited for the game,” Veronica began. “Because…”
As the Lodge girl trailed off, Jughead, Archie, and Betty looked at her.
“Ronnie?” Archie asked.
“Who’s she?” Veronica asked, ignoring the ginger’s question.
The three of them followed her gaze to the girl ordering something from Pop Tate at the counter.
Jughead was taken aback by you. He couldn’t put his finger on it, but there was something about you that just struck him. As you sat down in your booth, Jughead’s mind raced.
Was it the way you dressed? Or maybe—
“I’ve never seen her before,” Betty said, snapping Jughead out his thoughts. “But she can’t be new. No one transfers schools in the middle of the school year.”
“Should we invite her to sit with us?” Archie asked as he turned back to Veronica.
“Yeah, sure,” Ronnie said. “She looks— oh hello.”
At Veronica’s purr, everyone turned back to what she was looking at. Sam, Dean, and Castiel all entered Pop’s. The three men caught sight of you in your booth and sat down next to you and across from you. As the four of you began to talk, the teens tried to hear what you were saying but to no avail.
“So there’s a motel about a quarter mile ahead. Called the Moon Motel. Only one in town.” Dean said as he and Castiel sat across from you.
You nodded as Sam sat down next from you.
“Okay,” you said. “I ordered us all waters to start. Didn’t get you food though. Wasn’t sure what you were in the mood for.”
Dean cleared his throat as he picked up a menu and started reading it.
“Pie,” he proclaimed. “Cherry pie.”
Pie. You loved it. But it had made you sick as a dog when you had gotten—
The smile disappeared from your face and you quickly shook your head, removing that thought from your head. You wouldn’t think about that today.
“You okay?” Sam asked, looking at you.
You looked up and realized your brothers and the angel were looking at you.
“Uh, y-yeah,” you stammered, running a hand through your hair. “Just wondering what we’re gonna wear for the next few days. I mean, no offense, Dean, but you smell.”
Sam bit back a smile at your remark while Dean glared at you.
“I can get us some fake credit cards.” Cas cut in.
You rose your eyebrows at him.
“In this place?” you asked.
“I can try.” the angel replied.
You sighed as you sat back in your chair, picking your menu up.
“Alright.” you answered as the four of you entered a comfortable silence.
The teens watched you and the three others curiously.
“Who are they?” Betty asked quietly.
“I don’t know,” she said as she took a sip of her milkshake. “But I like the one that’s sitting next to the one in that trench coat.” she said slyly.
Archie groaned and Jughead’s face twisted up as if he had tasted something sour.
“That’s gross, Ronnie.” Betty said.
Veronica shrugged and the four of them resumed looking at the strangers across the room only to freeze when they saw you were looking straight back at them.
“Why don’t you take a picture?” you snapped loudly. “It’ll last longer.”
The men in your booth turned to look at the Core Four who quickly looked away, not wanting to face their wrath as well.
“Damn.” Jughead muttered.
Guess you didn’t like to play around.
Sam looked back at you after your outburst with an impressed expression on his face.
“I’m just hungry, okay?” you mumbled, looking back down at your menu.
“That’s my girl.” he said.
You gave a small smile before the silence enveloped your booth again. You glanced up again only to see the raven-haired teenager from the booth you had yelled at looking at you curiously. The other teens had their heads down, evidently scarred by your scolding.
But not him.
You debated yelling at him again before deciding you were too hungry to get into a fight at this time. You sighed, eyes going back to your menu.
What even was this place?
A/N: Send me feedback! Hope you guys are enjoying it so far!
Going through a rewatch I love how important the early motw episodes have been to set up the themes of this season so far…
1. Children are born innocent are not responsible for the actions of their parents (established very early in the season with consecutive episodes 12x03, 12x04, 12x05). Firmly confirmed by Dagon in 12x13 that this is relevant re: nephilim.
2. Dean is growing emotionally and being more open with his feelings. He is admitting to and saying out loud things he never would have previously. Mary admitting to not being ‘fine’ in 12x01 is crucial to this. He’s not coping well with Cas leaving (although he knows he will return) and Mary leaving, not sure that she’ll return. Dean later revealing that he’s worried, not mad (this is relevant to these early episodes where Cas is gone and he’s clearly unhappy about it), feeling like he and Sam deserved better from their mom, having cake instead of pie and not making a big deal out of it, admitting that ‘sublimation is kinda my thing’, letting Jody speak to him about his feelings….
3. Doing the ‘wrong thing’ for the ‘greater good’ is firmly established as the questionable core theme of 12x04, 12x05, 12x06.
4. ‘True’ family does not start or end with blood. Blood family can hurt and trap you, found family and even strangers can be your saviour (12x04, 12x05)….