I’m kinda tired of all of the “RT DAVIES ERA WHO WAS BESTEST WHO AND MOFFAT SUCKS” crap I keep seeing. Can we not blast one era and ignore the other’s faults? Can we actually be civilized and recognize that both eras have their failures and successes? Can we actually recognize that Russel Davies wrong some SHIT stories during his run? Can we actually admit to ourselves that our Rose-Tinted Glasses (lol Rose Tyler) and our Nostalgia are distorting our views of the past and its actual merits?
Yes, there were good episodes in RTD. But there are also good in Moffat - many of which are actually better than some of RTD’s episodes. Just like there are bad episodes in Moffat. Feel free to like either more than the other, but don’t ignore the flaws of one and rub the flaws of hte other in everyone’s faces. That’s hypocrisy.
Long Story Short - Your fangirlish obsession over David Tennant has clouded your judgement of an era of DW, leading to a misconception that RTD can do no wrong and that it is absolutely perfect and without flaw.