EX’s & OH’s
Kai Parker x Reader x Kol Mikaelson
word count : 5 352
warning : smut (threesome)
summary : Kai and Reader are dating and then out of the blue Kol (her ex) shows up after he comes back to life.
note : surprise😈🔥 / KEEP READING AFTER THE CUT
*Kai gif by lightwoodxalec / Kol gif by mikaelsonsource
Friday night and as usual everyone was at the Grill , having fun and dancing. It had become a regular thing for summer nights in Mystic Falls and lately she and Kai spent more and more time there with her friends who had surprisingly started warming up to her boyfriend. Or at least didn’t hate on him as much which was definitely a progress considering their previous attitude.
"I love slow songs !” said Y/N placing her hands on his chest while Kai’s hands found their way on her waist pulling her closer towards him.
"And I love your body this close to mine.” he whispered moving his hands a little lower. They had been together for almost a whole year now and still every time he touched her or kissed her or did something like that it drove her completely crazy. It was like the longer they were together the more magnified the feeling became.
Y/N looked up meeting his eyes which were bluer than ever though a bit darker in that moment. A small smile spread across his face and he slowly leaned in towards her , listening to her heart trying to leap out of her chest same as his the closer his lips got to hers. They couldn’t take their eyes off each other. It was always like that – the world could be falling apart but as long as they were in each others arms nothing else mattered.
"Hey creeper.” interrupted Damon. “Do you want to come and play pool or - ”
"I’ll go get us drinks.” she said pressing her lips against his for a second but as usual their ‘second’ turned into a whole moment and Kai pulled her closer to him , kissing her as if his life depended on it.
"Kai ? Are you coming or - “
"Coming – ” he replied , reluctantly letting go off his girl. His eyes following her through the crowd.
Y/N got to the bar quickly getting the bartender’s attention when someone’s hands snaked around her waist from behind pulling her closer. She could feel someone’s breath on her neck a moment before they rested their chin on her shoulder.
“You couldn’t wait 5 seconds huh ?”
"I have been waiting for almost 5 years , darling.” said a male voice with an unmistakable accent.
Y/N stumbled a little and turned around. It wasn’t possible but there he was , her boyfriend. Well , her ex-boyfriend with the same warm chocolate eyes and that smile capable of melting a snow cone. And a few metres behind him stood Kai looking at them with pure anger burning in his eyes.
"What is it ? Aren’t you happy to see me? Don’t tell me your friends had compelled away your memories of me after Jeremy staked me with the white oak.”
"Um …” she laughed nervously pushing his hands way noticing her boyfriend making his way towards them. “I clearly had more to drink that I thought cuz you can’t be real.”
"Everything OK here ?” asked Kai putting his arm around her shoulders with a smile on his face , though Y/N knew better. He might be smiling but on the inside he was burning up.
"Yeah , mate. Just having a reunion with my girlfriend – ”
"Y-your girlfriend ?” said Kai a little amused. “Yeah , no. Sorry to break it to you but she is my girlfriend. Y/N , do you know this person or should I – ”
"That’s um … Kol Mikaelson , my um .. my ex , I guess ? He died. I mean Jeremy killed him to get the cure f-for Elena.”
Kai glanced at her then at Kol , realising who he was which only made his grip tighten around his girl. There was no way he’d let this guy take Y/N away from him. No. Not after everything he had been through , everything they had been through. No, but he also didn’t feel like taking on an original and getting himself killed again either so he decided to play nice at least for the time being.
"I’m Kai. Kai Parker.” he smirked , outstretching his hand to shake the original’s.
Kol glanced at Kai’s hand and refused to shake it. His eyes were fixed on Y/N and only her. He should’ve known she’d move on with someone else. It had been five years and the real world hadn’t stood still but somehow it hurt him seeing someone else wrap his hand around her waist like that. Yet he was happy she had found love again.
"OKAY you two. This is um awkward enough without the death stares.” she smiled nervously. “I will be back in 5 minutes and I expect to find both of you alive and the bar without any innocent victims okay?
"Anything my girl wants.” smiled Kai pulling her into a deep passionate kiss before letting her go.
"Whatever you say darling.” smiled Kol.
Y/N went to the bathroom splashing cold water on her face. Kai and Kol together. It was a bit much for her seeing them both at the same time , being quite literally stuck between them. More than one thought crept inside her mind but she quickly shoved all of them away and kept shoving them away every time they tried to fight their way out.
No , no. Stop that. she thought , closing her eyes.
She braced her hands on the sink while trying to calm down her breathing and hear beat. It took her a couple of minutes and when finally she walked outside and glanced at the bar , the boys seemed to get along or at least didn’t appear they had tried to kill each other yet which was more than she could ask. A small smile showed on her face and she walked over to the pool table , hoping to maybe catch up with her friends. An advice from Caroline would be perfect at this point but there was no one there but a couple of strangers playing pool.
"Y/N…” whispered Kol in her ear wrapping his hands around her waist “ I know you remember us. I know -”
"Stop. I am in love with Kai -”
"You can love us both.” he insisted.
Y/N caught a glimpse of her boyfriend starring at them from the bar , obviously listening in to their conversation. There was a smile on his face but she could almost feel his anger radiating towards her and Kol. There was something else too but she just couldn’t put her finger on it. Usually by this point whoever dared to touch her had started choking or had gotten their neck snapped.
"You are right. I can.” she turned around, pushing his hands away. “But I am not Katherine. I don’t play with people’s feelings.”
Y/N pushed her way through the crowd and took Kai’s hand ready to leave before any of the boys does something violent but her boyfriend had other intentions. He cupped her face and kissed her like he had never kissed her before , his hands moving towards her ass pulling her towards him while her hands tangled in his hair pulling him even closer as if it was possible. Their lips moved fiercely against each other while their tongues swirled together until he left her completely breathless.
"You are mine and only mine. Make sure you remember that.”
Y/N looked at him with confusion which only grew when he grinned at her ex-boyfriend who had followed her. What was up with those two? There was something – different about their eyes in that moment.
"Would you like to come over and continue the party at our place ?” asked Kai making her heart literally stop. There were devils dancing in his eyes and the way he was looking at her in that moment turned her skin on fire. Did he really just said what she thought he did ?
"Only if Y/N is up for it.”
"What do you say princess ?” asked Kai spinning her around. One of his hands wound around her waist and the other slipped in her short shorts while he nibbled on her earlobe. She glanced at Kol who by the looks of it was this close to losing it. “You can love us both tonight.”
Her mind suddenly got so clouded it was hard for her to concentrate on anything. Those thoughts she had shoved away flooded her mind and to add more to it , Kai’s fingers started to play not caring they were still at the Grill and people were watching.
"I will never survive a night with you two. You will break me.” she moaned quietly.
"Promise not to break you darling.” said Kol. “We will be gentle.”
"Mmhmmm…” hummed Kai.
Y/N closed her eyes for a split second trying to think when someone’s lips crashed against hers , recognising them the same instant - Kol’s. A low growl came from Kai’s throat right in her ear and his grip on her tightened. He was both jealous and into it at the same time , it was driving her nuts. What had gotten into him that night ? First he asks her to dance when usually she has to beg him to and now this.
"You never share –”
"Tonight and only tonight I do.”
"What um … I – ” she was barely able to form any words. Only turned around looking into Kai’s eyes asking a silent question. He gave her the slightest nod and finally she said yes.
Not a minute later they were already outside the bar and by the car. Y/N opened the passenger door but Kol pulled her in the back with him not wasting any time while Kai hit the gas so hard , the pedal almost snapped in two.
"You haven’t changed a bit.” whispered her ex kissing her neck while his hand moved up and down on her hip. “Stubborn and strong willed as hell but when your boyfriend wants something you just can’t say no.”
Y/N glanced at Kai , meeting his eyes in the review mirror. How it was that he always got what he wanted and why did he want this ? Surely Kol being an original would never stop Kai from trying to kill him but – what had they been talking about while she left them alone ? Was Kai on vervain ?
"You two have lost it.”
"No. You are the one who will lose it as soon as we walk inside.” grinned Kai.
"Come on darling. You know we both love you and would do anything to please you.” said Kol . his voice almost a whisper. “Think about it – four hands roaming your body , two sets if lips kissing every inch…”