In The Wrong Hands Part 2 (Reggie Mantle x Reader)
Okay so here is part 2 of In the wrong hands reggie mantle imagine. Hopefully everyone enjoys this part as much as they did the first and I am so grateful to all of the positive feedback that I am getting from everyone and will be open to any requests that you have for me.
Shocked you stood up and looked at
the furious Cheryl with wide eyes, trying to think a reason as to why they
would be sitting like that for a “biology project”, you tried but nothing came
to mind. Your heart was beating rapidly and you couldn’t think of anything else
besides that maybe the flirtatious interaction earlier that day was not just a one-sided
thing. Maybe Reggie wasn’t as faithful as you thought…
Sitting back down you placed your
hands on your head still trying to think of something, anything that didn’t come
to the conclusion that Reggie was possibly cheating on you. You heard Cheryl huff
and then the faintest tapping sound of her nails dialing a number. Looking up
once again you saw fire in Cheryl’s eyes and you knew that she was going to go
off. She shot you a pleading look for you not to stop her and then you heard
the gruff voice on the other end of the phone.
“Why the hell is Veronica Lodge sitting
all cozy on your lap in this Instagram post?” Cheryl said with an eerily calm tone
to her voice. You couldn’t hear what was being said on the other end but you
hoped that it was Reggie explaining that it was all a misunderstanding and that
it wasn’t his idea.
“I hope you can explain everything
to Y/N because to me it looks like you are cheating on her and you better pray
to god that that isn’t true.” Cheryl’s voice was sweet again before she hung up
“It looks like we might have to
train the girls a little harder at practice tomorrow, especially Miss. Veronica
Lodge.” She said turning to look at you, a devilish smile ghosting her lips,
sighing you gestured for the two of you to leave. You decided that you would talk
to Reggie tomorrow, the anxiety of today had exhausted you too much and you
just wanted to be home.
Once you were home you prayed to
anybody that tomorrow was going to be better before you let your blankets devour
you in their warmth. Tomorrow would be better…
That next morning you woke up to
multiple texts from Reggie apologizing and trying to explain what had happened.
please answer me. I swear there’s nothing going on between me and veronica…
baby I love you so much. Honest to god nothing has happened and nothing will
happen. I only have my eyes on you.
The frantic texts had calmed your
aching heart and you replied that the two of you would talk today and that you
loved him too. You were still nervous about having such a discussion but you
You were headed for your front door
when you heard honking from what you assumed was Cheryl Blossom’s cherry red 1961
Chevrolet Impala. Slipping on your shoes you rushed out to see Cheryl cranking
up her music and honking impatiently for you to hurry up. Giggling you ran
towards the car and the two of you sped off to school. Thoughts of Reggie and
Veronica had faded away and your brain was bursting with the new cheer
choreography that Cheryl was chattering on about.
The school parking lot came quickly
into view and you scanned the cars to see where Reggie might be, you spotted
him standing around with Moose and some other jocks. Smiling you were just
about to get out of Cheryl’s car to hug him… but without warning he was tackled
into a hug by none other than Veronica Lodge. Paralyzed, you couldn’t move a
muscle, your mouth was agape as you watched the scene unfold.
Veronica pulling away from Reggie, Veronica
leaning up and grabbing a handful of his hair and finally Veronica smashing her
red lips onto his. When she pulled away there was red lipstick staining Reggie’s
lips. Your heart lurched into your throat and you could not look away. Cheryl
had already slammed her car door and marched over to the scene, her red hair
billowing behind her as if they were the flames to the fire that was burning in
her eyes. She yanked the dark haired beauty off of Reggie and was undeniably
cussing her out but you didn’t hear a thing she said, your brain was unable to
process the event that had unfolded before you.
You looked into Reggie’s eyes and
found his apologetic gaze looking back at you. He broke away from the group
that had formed around him and rushed towards Cheryl’s car, lips still stained
red. You hadn’t realized it but your eyes had let a flood loose, Reggie’s hand touched
your tear-stained cheek, apologizing profusely.
“Y/N I don’t know why she did that.”
Reggie’s words snapped you out of your daze.
“ Why would she do that if there
was nothing between you two Reggie? What about that Instagram post yesterday?
That obviously was not just a misunderstanding, a girl wouldn’t kiss a guy or
sit in his lap like that if nothing was going on. So why don’t you tell me the
truth. What is going on Reggie?” You fired off questions viciously as more
tears streamed down your face. Reggie was left speechless unable to explain his
Getting out of the car you stormed
your way over to the still flaming Cheryl and dragged her into the school and to the girls locker
room, not wanting anyone else to see the continuation of your emotional
Okay so I know I am going to have to do a part 3 and I am pretty good with cliffhangers but I started getting a really bad headache while i was finishing up this part and will be writing and uploading more when I dont have a headache ! thank you to everyone for all of your support and if you want to be tagged in any other upcoming parts please do not hesitate to let me know!