I honestly think that the old newbies should come back and join the new newbies, it would be wonderful. On seasons 4 and 5 the newbies had to share the spotlight with half the originals, so of course they would be overshadowed, but it doesn’t mean we didn’t love them. If they joined the New Directions with the new newbies it would be completely amazing!! Think this through: Marley has a sweet personality and such a beautiful voice. The twins are funny, nice and weird. Ryder is the cute, charming and a little silly jock. Jane is the proud black girl with a fucking powerful voice. Jake is the damn hot stud. Spencer is the badass jock, who looks like a greek god. Kitty is our beloved head bitch. Roderick is the chubby shy kid with an amazing vocal. Unique is our transgender badass diva.
They’re such a charismatic, talented, powerful team, and they wouldn’t be compared with half the originals in the club because they’re all in college. The New New Directions would be THEIR thing, and they would rock it! And they could be as good as the Original New Directions, because this time the club would be all about them, their club, their fight, their family, their beautiful friendship, the family relationship that the newbies didn’t have with the originals. The new glee club would be their family, all about them, coached by Rachel and Kurt, and it would be lovely. They could be out new underdogs. The fresh start of Will’s legacy.
Some love for the Glee guys! Finn, Puck, Artie, Kurt, Blaine, Sam, Mike, Matt, Jake, Ryder, Spencer, Mason, Roderick, Joe, Rory, Will, Figgins, Burt, Sebastian, Hunter, Adam, Elliot, Brody, Dave, we love you all!
I wish Marley, Jake, Kitty, Ryder and Unique could have come back in season 6 and be in New Directions. Then Madison, Mason, Jane, Roderick and Spencer could have joined. That’s 10 members. Then they just needed 2 more. Alistair and Myron could have still joined or just find 2 more characters. I would have preferred that over Warblers/New Directions mega group. The Warblers should have remained competition. It would have been interesting to see a married Klaine be competition rivals.
Sometimes I fantasize what S4 would have been if the writers had used the newbies and TGP “winners” as the new team expies: Harmony (Rachel), Kitty (Quinn), Jake (Puck), Ryder (Finn), Unique (Mercedes/Kurt), Marley (Tina), Betty (Artie), Joe (Mike), Sugar (Brittany), Rory (Sam), and Bree (Santana).