These were the scenes Alex Drake insinuated herself into Spencer’s life.
701: Hanna “dreams” of Spencer giving her an idea of a way of escaping BUT, this is actually Alex trying to find out if Hanna knew who killed Charlotte.
708: Spencer sits in her living room in an argyle sweater looking through her photo album, except this is actually Alex looking through the “perfect life her twin sister had.
710: Spencer visits Toby to say goodbye before he leaves Rosewood. This is in fact Alex, and there was a MAJOR clue we all missed. She is wearing the same argyle sweater from the ending of 708; the scene above this one.
715: The famous airport scene. One of the biggest scenes that bought so many people on board the Twincer theory. Spencer was so unlike Spencer in the scene and there’s even a dead giveaway when Alex’s accent changes for a split second from American to British.
718: Now THIS scene was one of the BIGGEST clues to Spencer having a twin and this being her twin. The way she was acting, it was so unlike Spencer. Toby even makes a comment along the lines of “That doesn’t sound like the Spencer I know.” We also posted about this scene here which you can check out.
I promise you, if the show ends with ‘it was all a dream’ or with Addison and friends becoming the next victims and getting texts from ‘B’, I will swim to America, hit Marlene over the head with a rock and send myself to Radley.
The way they showed it made me think that the bullet wound is going to be how we can differentiate between Spencer and her twin.. And now that we know Jenna didn’t shoot Spencer, since it wasn’t her gun, and Mary probably didn’t either (she’s had opportunities to kill her since then and she hasn’t) I honestly think that maybe the writers are paying homage to the book and the twin wanted Spencer dead so she could take her life. But when her twin failed she started the end game.
Okay, what is the deal with Aria’s file? What on earth could be her secret? A secret that would put EZRA in jail, and make him pick Nicole over her?
AD says the following to Aria:
“Jessica DiLaurentis kept excellent records. If Ezra knew what was in your file he would definitely choose Nicole, and she would be visiting him in jail.”
Why would something …
put EZRA in jail
AND have him pick Nicole
One thing we know for sure is it had to be something that happened BEFORE Jessica’s murder, since it is something Jessica found out.
This can be interpreted in two ways:
Jessica DiLaurentis found something incriminating about Ezra that Aria has kept a secret. But…. why would Ezra hate Aria because of it? Why would Ezra blame Aria if this came out? What is she willing to keep secret about Ezra that she would go against her best friends for? Does Aria know a secret about Ezra that if it came out would put him in jail? Okay, there are a few possibilities here, but why would it make Ezra choose Nicole over Aria? Thats the part I just dont understand. Ezra could be upset that Jessica found out something about him, but why would it make him give up his love for Aria???
Jessica found out something about Aria that would cause Ezra to hate herand to do something that would put him in jail….Is this signifying that Ezra would kill Aria if he found out this secret?
I feel like the following photo is significant. The 4 glasses represent the four main girls, Spencer, Hanna, Aria & Emily.
By shattering a glass, it is a symbol that she is no longer one of them, that she is going against the group to protect whatever is in her file.
The girls have always stuck together, so it has to be something HUGE if she is willing to go over to the dArk side.
(Side Note: I swear to GOD if Marlene messes this up and its something stupid Im going to jump off a cliff)
There has always been something sketchy about Aria. I’ve written a million posts about it and don’t want to go through every little thing again because we’ll be here all day, but I do want to go over a few significant things.
Aria and Eddie Lamb
When Aria goes into Radley to get info on Bethany’s old roommate, Eddie Lamb recognizes her and says he feels like they have met before. Aria acts REALLY BIZARRE in this scene. She is obviously hiding something. She has some kind of connection to Radley Sanitarium.
Aria and Jason
A part of me has always believed that Jason is A. I have written theories about it. He has always had a thing for Aria. The weirdest thing was when he had all of those close-up photos of her sleeping. He claimed Alison took them-but I just dont buy that. And later A had the same photos in his/her lair.
Then there is a very similar scene in later seasons, of Aria hanging up her creepy doll photographs in a dark room. It is a parallel to when Jason is in the darkroom with the pictures of her.
Its possible that whatever is in her file has something to do with Jason. This could lead in to why it would cause Ezra to choose Nicole over Aria.
Aria and Mona
What the hell did Aria whisper to Mona at this moment that had her running scared?????? Aria and Mona have always had an interesting relationship and suspicious conversations.
Aria had the mannequin family framed in her Dollhouse bedroom. The look on her face seems to convey that she KNOWS SOMETHING. Who/why they were taken there.
There are so many crazy possibilities as to what is in Aria’s file. The last few episodes of the show have really depressed me. I’ve been majorly disappointed in the writing and reveals. I am really hoping they give us something shocking and amazing for Aria’s secret.
Literally the entire episode I feel Troian made sure to emphasize the watch Spencer was wearing, it was in multiple shots and really stood out to me - not to mention Spencer has worn a watch almost the entire season. So it really stood out that for some reason in the airport scene Spencer’s wrist was bare.
Wren and ‘Spencer’ were arguing, they haven’t seen each other in years correct? Why would he come back to Rosewood and seek out Spencer? Why would they argue like that if they hadn’t been in constant contact and why would Spencer not mention it once?
And when Spencer introduced Wren and Ezra she referred to the fact that Wren was almost her brother in law on multiple occasions. Well, he was engaged to Melissa, I wouldn’t call that multiple times. Now if that’s Spencer’s twin, we know Spencer and Wren had a little thing. So as a snide remark she might’ve included the plural meaning as in “well he’s been with both my sisters”.
I honestly believe Spencer’s twin is Bethany. Hence why Jessica would visit her and have her call her Auntie Jess (Jessica would be Spencer’s aunt as well, so if Bethany is Spencer’s twin then tada, Aunt Jess). Also explains Bethany’s drawings of Jessica in demon form and with “liar” written across her head. In hind sight, that could also have been of Mary - if she found out Mary was her mom.
We also know Doctor Cochran said he delivered only two of Mary’s babies and we’ve been thinking there’s a third. Who’s to say a nurse didn’t deliver Bethany/Spencer’s twin while Cochran got Spencer ready for the Hastings or for some other reason couldn’t deliver the twin. And honestly I wouldn’t put it past Peter. He knew it was hard enough for Veronica to handle one of his love children, having her deal with two/twins? So why not send the other to someone else and keep it a secret? Peter has so many damn secrets. I wouldn’t be surprised.
Maybe Spoby isn’t end game, but Toby/Twincer is? If it’s Bethany, they kind of have a connection anyways (Radley/his mother). Toby’s starting to seem more and more as a likely candidate for AD; what with Mona’s clarification that the game was lovingly made and we know Toby is a carpenter. 214 is related to Toby. Jenna seems to have a huge part of AD’s plan and Toby/Jenna have history. Toby probably poisoned Yvonne. That whole scene was just odd to say the least. Toby literally forced Spencer into Radley by faking his death - who does that? And he knew what it would do to her and he didn’t care and yet through everything has he even apologized for that? Honestly?
EDIT: If he has been with Bethany/Twincer this whole time and used Spencer as a means to destroy her for having the life Bethany wanted it makes perfect sense for him to manipulate her into loving him so much that when he “died” she’d have to go to Radley to cope and put her in the same position that Bethany grew up in. A perfect payback if you will for having the life she wanted.
Police Station @2:53 Hotel room @8:17 Radley Hotel Lobby @12:13 Playground @15:16 Police Station @17:12 Radley Hotel Lobby @21:44 Ezra’s apartment @26:03 Toby’s cabin @31:55 Toby’s cabin @32:03 (no watch) Spencer’s barn @35:48
The Spencer character changed her outfit 3 times within 24 hours.
You truly were the best part of this 7-year journey.
I cannot believe it’s the end of an era. I just wanted to take the time and say thank you to ALL the brilliant and wonderful and dedicated pll theorists out there. Even when the show gave us filler/boring episodes or when they wouldn’t give us legit answers and I’d been like “what’s the point of watching anymore?” you were always giving us your best work! The best part of watching pll was staying up all night reading theories about who black widow was, board shorts, the popular twin theories, red coat, one of the main girls being the ultimate -A, who killed wilden, who killed ian, who ‘killed’ alison, who’s bethany, who’s charles, NAT club, etc.
SO THANK YOU FOR SUCH AN AMAZING EXPERIENCE!
And of course I’ll miss the most the Aria and Wren theories because no matter what happens on the show once you’re aboard THERE’S NO WAY OUT!
7x11 has alluded so much to A.D. Possibly being Bethany Young and Spencer’s Twin.
The whole speech that Veronica gave about how heartbreaking it is to have to be born in Radley and left alone was a huge clue to Bethany being born there and left there while they only took her twin sister Spencer!
This whole episode gave me weird feelings about Spencer and that Lost Woods Resort scene where we saw her…it didn’t even feel like Spencer…
Did you notice how scared Vernoica was when Spencer said that Mary told her something? There has to be more than Mary being her mother.
Also, I just realized something: Jessica had an affair with Mr. Young?!?! The only man we know she had an affair with was Peter Hastings…Could he be this Mr. Young?!? And let’s not forget the fact that Jessica asked Bethany to call her Auntie.
At the end of this weeks episode in Mona’s lair we see a photo in Mona’s lair of what looks like a male and female kissing:
The camera panned over the image on purpose, and it was definitely a clue for fans to start speculating. The photo is a picture of WREN and SPENCER! See for yourself:
As I have a read through the comments it actually got quite interesting. The photo is from episode 104 when Wren and Spencer kissed outside the Edgewood Motor Court. The number 1 and 4 represents A and D, respectively. Another pick up is the Edgewood Motor Court has links to Jenna, where we’ve seen her link to the number 214, a number that is prominently reappearing.
I know this could be fans reading into it way too much, but I TRULY think that these subtle clues have been given for a reason! Is Mona onto something and is Wren Uber A/AD?
I read a lot of books, mostly criminal mysteries. I have a bachelors degree in psychology. I’ve always loved to try to get into the mind of the killer, to understand from a psychological stand point why they do the things they do.
There are many different types of killers. One type that always interests me is the sociopathic serial killer who continuously kills the same person over and over again. Let me explain- a boy was sexually/physically/verbally abused by his mother as a child. His mother eventually dies. When this boy grows up he begins to kill women who remind him of his mother. Every time he rapes and kills a woman, in his mind he is killing his mother over and over again.
It’s been said that A’s motive lies in a tragic love story.
The finale is called Til Death Do Us Part.
Ezra is A.
He has severe mental illness.
He is a sociopath.
He was in love with a girl.
She went missing.
He searched for her.
He couldn’t find her.
She was dead.
He never got over it, it consumed him.
Ezra now seeks his dead lover out in other women who in some way remind him of her.
He falls in love with a new woman, but in his head it’s his dead lover.
He orchestrates a plan to make her go missing.
So that he can search for her and find her.
So that he can finally get what he always wanted- he can find his lover.
This time he would find her.
This time she wouldn’t be dead.
Ezra has done this multiple times.
He meets Alison and falls in love with her.
He sends her A texts to scare her into running away.
He dedicates his entire existence in trying to find her; including stalking her best friends
He writes a book about it.
He gets side tracked when he believes Alison may be dead.
He meets Aria and falls in love with her.
He builds the dollhouse and locks her up inside.
He helps the cops find the dollhouse.
He finds and saves her.
Things don’t work out.
He meets Nicole and falls in love with her.
He orchestrates a plan to get her captured overseas.
He relentlessly searches for her
He finds her and does everything he can to help her, including blowing Aria off and not telling her he is engaged to someone else.
He writes a book about it.
He continuously lives out this sequence of events.
He has an overwhelming need to finally find the woman he loved, the woman who he searched for but couldn’t find, the woman who died.
Til Death Do They Part
This was a subtle clue that Ezra is A, black hoodie, and his helper has been Red Coat. Together they are AD.