So when I dreamt this, I was very sick, and was so fevered I had been hallucinating while awake. In my dream, I was just a simple baker, living in a kingdom and specializing in cake. I fought my way to become the king baker, through a mix of bake-offs, duels, and plain old murder. I lost nearly everyone I cared about along the way, as a result of my ruthless methods, until I was standing on a cliff with my one remaining friend in the world, and she pushed me off the cliff, so she could become the king baker. Then I woke up, fell asleep, and had the exact same dream three more times.
Look. I get why you want JD to be a perfect angel that did no wrong cause let's face it. He's hot. But the reality as it stands is that he is a murder. Plain and simple. He murdered Heather C, Kurt and Ram, and even tried to kill his "beloved" Veronica because she didn't want to murder people anymore. He's a psychopath. Or at the very least has psychopathic tendencies. He's not perfect. He did wrong. LOTS of wrong. Don't be a child. Accept the facts.