Another Pink Diamond Theory.. sorta

A stupid thought came to me while re watching back to the moon.

Pink Diamond’s mural is drastically different from the murals of the other three diamonds.

White, yellow and Blue all have an ethereal floating stance. 

Pink’s mural is standing almost as if she’s freshly bursting out of the ground. To me it looks like a mural of a newly emerged diamond.

Stewing on that thought I wondered where she was and what she was doing as her “sisters” gained control of so many planets. Then the thought hit me. What if the Earth was truly hers. Diamonds are quite large and are supposed to have a lot of power. A planet that had enough life to bring a diamond to life might truly be rare. A planet that was lush with life to the extreme and have vast resources would be needed.

Considering the size and power of a diamond I can imagine it would create quite the impressive emergence hole on the planet they were born on. Now where on Earth has there been a enormous change in geography that is missing?

Making earth the place of a diamond’s possible birth and death.


So I was reading this post about the temple fusion possibly being the thing that took down Pink Diamond and I–

“Who cares about her shield? Her huge sword is what I remember.”

(meanwhile, three seasons ago)

I don’t know about you, but THAT’S the kind of sword I’d use to shatter a diamond.


Rose Quartz and Pink Diamond

Something still seems off to me about the story we’ve been told, that Rose shattered Pink Diamond.  Garnet at the end of Bubbled never says outright that it happened, just that Rose always did what was right for Earth, and her answers aren’t even evasions because Steven only asks why nobody told him about Pink Diamond, not whether it was true or not.   We haven’t heard from Pearl yet, and Jasper has been conveniently silenced.

The only firm confirmation we have is from Eyeball Ruby who is dumb as a box of hammers.  Not to mention that there’s a giant flaw in her story:

Eyeball Ruby:  I saw it with my own eye!  I watched the leader of the Crystal Gems, Rose Quartz, shatter Pink Diamond!

Eyeball Ruby:  Who cares about her shield!?  Her huge sword is what I remember.

Bismuth:  It can cut through a gem’s physical form in an instant!  Destroying the body…but never the gem.

Eyeball Ruby remembers Rose Quartz wielding the sword that is literally incapable of smashing gems.   There’s still something we’re not being told about what happened.