Context: Me (and high elf rouge), a Cleric (a halfling), and Four humans (three fighters and a wizard) wake up in a dark arena with no memories of the past few months. We eventually stumble upon a chest that contains three gemstones. My character ends up with one, the Cleric ends up with two. Later on, we’re distracted investigating a dead body
Cleric (ooc): I’m gonna sneak behind the Rouge and pickpocket her for her gem
DM: ok, I’ll tell you privately if you are successful
Cleric: *rolls a critical failure in slight of hand*
Me: *rolls 12 percepton*
Fighter (ooc): *dies laughing* Yeah DM go ahead and tell him if he succeeded
Cleric: I CAN EXPLAIN!!