Just curious if you did a break down of ESNY lyrics. id like to see your take on it.
I haven’t, but howbow now?
A lot of fans think Ever Since New York is about that unholiest of fauxmances, Haylor, since the primary stuntin’ took place in NYC. Listening to the lyrics, I agree with that.
Picture it: NYC, December 2012. 1D is at a career high, having played to a sold out Madison Square Garden crowd. This level of hotness must have smelled like blood in the water to fake ass fame vampire, Taylor Swift and her team. So commence fakelationship stuntin’!
I’ll show you what skeeved me out the most. The hotel ho strolls:
They’d make sure to pap Harry coming and going so that fans would infer that the s-e-x must have surely taken place. Classy. This is how music is marketed. Why God?
Meanwhile, all this fakery was apparently taking a toll on Louis:
And the Elounor awkwardness was later mocked by Grimmy:
And it only got worse from there. By New Year’s Eve, Tay Tay was reveling in this Times Square look-at-me spectacle:
Harry, not so much:
This was the point where 1DHQ really dug in with the closeting. Payzer 2.0 launched December 2012, too. Not a coincidence. This is where reality must have really set in. And this is just based on what we can piece together. God only knows what kinds of conversations took place bts to put all this in place. But I can imagine it was dehumanizing and demoralizing. Aggressive hetero stuntin’ would become the new normal for 1D.
So that’s the kind of stuff that would’ve influenced ESNY. It’s easy to understand why he still feels some type of way about it.
Tell me something, tell me something
You don’t know nothing, just pretend you do
I need something, so tell me something new
Choose your words ‘cause there’s no antidote
For this curse or what’s it waiting for
Must desert you just before you go
Harry is my people because he comes out the gate swinging. I’m guessing this first verse is directed at Taylor. Being older and having been in the business longer, Harry is looking to her to make him understand why this needs to happen. He wants her to help him make peace with it. But Taylor is the monster showbiz created. She has no wisdom to offer. So Harry is left grappling with this closeting, which feels like a curse. And “must desert you before you go” feels like a reference to the end of Haylor, where she played the role of good girl who got dumped…again.
There she is alone on a boat…deserted. This is what had to happen before she could go for good. It’s a reference to the fakery–knowing how things will play out before they even happen.
Oh, tell me something I don’t already know
Oh, tell me something I don’t already know
Again, Harry’s desperate for something more profound. I’m sure his team was telling him this was good for him, that it was in his best interests personally and professionally. But Harry isn’t really buying it.
Brooklyn saw me, empty avenues
There’s no water inside this swimming pool
Almost over, that’s enough from you
I’ve been praying, I never did before
Understand I’m talking to the walls
And I’ve been praying ever since New York
Harry was able to venture out into the boroughs, unbothered. But in Manhattan? It was lights, cameras, stunt time! And Haylor is like a empty swimming pool: an artifice without purpose. Just like a pool needs water to fulfill its purpose, a relationship needs a real emotional bond to fulfill its purpose. And of course, there wasn’t one. Harry’s counting the days until Taylor sails her fraudulent ass away on that boat. Enough! Same Harry. Same. These are trying times and Harry’s literally praying his way through it–searching for strength where he hadn’t looked before. That’s how profoundly hurtful this experience is for him And he’s been praying ever since. We know why.
You’re certainly not required to like someone that your favorite celebrity is dating. Being a fan doesn’t mean you have to like everything they do or everyone they date.
But not liking that person does not give you the right to try to convince everyone that that relationship is a fake stunt. And it doesn’t give you the right to harass that person’s social media and threaten their lives. I guess basic respect is gone out the window in these modern times. :(
this is the interview , where Liam says that Harry introduced him and Danielle, as well as Louis and Eleanor.here is the possible story. Louis wasn’t interviewed he was on the other side of the room, when he heard his name he asked ‘what are you talking about’ don’t interpret it :)
You're dead right about those cupcakes being prooomooo. Idk how closely you follow Andy, but the Fat Feeder (chick that made the cakes) is his alleged girlfriend's sister. And said girlfriend is good friends with Sophia. So it's all around promo for everyone. And why are there baby cupcakes at a lady-lad bro party anyway? Ugh free Liam from this madness!
I don’t follow Andy closely but no surprise at what he’s doing. I do think Andy is
the real deal in terms of 1D friends and he’s laid kinda low and even shaded
the official narrative in the recent past. But I think he’s been drafted
because using the douche canoe crew (the three dudes Liam started
hanging with to help sell Sophiam) is not an option since they were all
team Sophia and we’re employed for the purposes of that narrative.
And yes, baby themed cupcakes, randomly
appearing over a month after the kid was born isn’t very bro. Why were
they there? Who is that slow on the congrats anyway?? Niall?? LMAO! It’s
obviously targeted at young, naive, female fans who swoon over this
kinda thing without giving the context much thought.
Like I said
my earlier tags, it’s a recycled stunt. And recycled stunts are evidence
AGAINST a thing being an organic happening. In other words, it’s
planned with a particular narrative mission in mind.
Let’s see some
of the greatest hits in what I like to call, fakery from the bakery.
Look away, Harry. I know you used to be a baker and these are
abominations in your eyes.
Of course, Elounor are the OGs of this foolery.
Fauxmance and Disney promo? Genius.
That mess wasn’t even the best. Behold the shady af tribute to the mother of modern bearding, Taylor Swift. Why ever would they go there?? Everybody’s in on this joke except 75% of this fandom.
The cake stunts didn’t end with Elounor 1.0. This one isn’t even funny. Because Louis was dealing with the very recent loss of his mother when this happened:
The look on his face says it all. Not ok and no further comment.
But not to be outdone, Liam has done more than his share of cake stuntin’. Cakes everywhere. The Funky Buddha promo cake and the cake Danielle allegedly got him:
Please note this was August 2012 and Payzer 1.0 was probably over at this point. This was post fandom famous Ziam/Payzer Vegas showdown. And as far as we can tell, it looked like Zayn won that battle and ultimately the war. So this explains the need for extra strength cake stuntin’…I mean, I guess by 1DHQ logic.
Cake stunts continued with Sophiam. As always, aided and abetted by friend of Modest, Funky Buddha.
In hindsight, the emphasis on Sophia was obviously promo meant to set her up as an Instamodel post scheduled break-up, which came later that year. I tell ya, all the cake stuff is planned and deliberate.
More Zerrie cake fakes: That one time the garbage press told us this was Zayn’s birthday cake courtesy of Perrie…
…but Zayn’s family showed and proved that this was actually Zayn’s birthday cake:
Zayn was never seen with the Hulk cake. Surprise, surprise. And the cake beat goes on with Gigi and her Zayn stand-in with the photoshopped tattoos.
Now the pastry aided deception includes babies. Sad but true.
As for Niall, there was this weirdness a few years ago:
Hahahaha, no. Somebody tried it. This was an insult to Niall and great promo for 1DHQ co-conspirator The Sun. This implied co-sign was meant to tell us to believe 1DHQ’s lies as told by The Sun. Because if you can’t trust Niall, who can you trust? I see what you did there.
So for some try-to-get-inside-the-mind-of-teenaged-girls logic fail, cakes are supposed to = rayl. I guess 1DHQ thinks the kiddies love cake and no one would ever use precious, delicious cake in the interest of faking it because precious delicious. Yeah, ok.
Okay so I spend so much time reading One Direction fanfic that I feel the need to organize all my best readings in this post and let here for reference. This probably will be so f*cking long cause I read most of the ships. So here we go.