Say at least one bad thing about every primarch, plus the emperor if you want. Maybe even the other custodes too if you're feeling like it.
*Sips Hot chocolate and pulls out a piece of paper.*
I. “Despite his knightly demeanor and all his talk of honor and loyalty, The Lion was far too willing to keep secrets, even when he could and should have told the truth. He believed he should have been chosen Warmaster simply because he was the 1st primarch ever created. He was unable to relate to mortals and even his own Legion. He demanded respect and obedience, but rarely gave it to others, even his own brothers and adopted father.”
II. REDACTED (They made the mistake of facing me, they should have fled and lived a little longer. Not that they could have escaped the Ten Thousand and I.)
III. “For all his talk of perfection, Fulgrim failed to see the perfection in humility and doing his duty, All he ever wanted was glory and adoration. He wanted everyone to sing his praises from the highest mountaintops and the lowest of gutters.”
IV “Perturabo never should have been given command of a legion. Like Fulgrim he wanted praise and glory for his achievement. While paranoia is a strength, Perturabo saw criticism and enemies everywhere, even when it did not exist and even among his own family. He believed Rogal Dorn was his rival but this rivalry was a product of his own deranged mind. His treatment of his Legionaries was sick and disgusting, While victory cannot be achieved without sacrifice, Perutrabo murdered one in ten of his own legionaries when he was reunited with them, simply because they did not meet his achievable standards. He spent their lives like a spoiled prince spends gold, War was never a necessary evil for him, it was an equation and a bill at his doorstep, One he was too eager to solve by spending his own son’s lives.”
V “The Khan was always a mercurial soul. A paradox. Reckless one moment, overcautious and dawdling the next. A bloodthirsty hound and a diplomat. A admirable, cultured and philosophical man, and a barbarian that mounted the heads of his foes on his jetbike, In his desire to not be a tyrant, he neglected discipline and too many White Scars considered becoming traitors, yet in his widsom, he granted them atonement through battle. In short, he traveled down many paths,and ran off the road constantly, Thankfully the one road he stayed on was one of loyalty.”
VI “ Leman,.. Like Dorn, I admire him for his steadfast loyalty and envy him for how simple things are for him Simply tear the Emperor’s enemies apart and follow orders like a good little corgi. Yet, he is a hypocrite, He claimed his Rune Preists used the power of Fenris, when one could smell the musk of the Warp on them a mile away. The culture of Fenris may have saved the VIth legion from tearing itself apart, but it was anathema to the Imperial Truth. He always assumed the worst in Magnus and that he was always right, So self-righteous, so eager to charge with his axe raised high. So changeable. One second he’s offering you a tankard of Mjol, The next, you’re head’s been removed and being chewed on by one of his wolves and he’s bedded your wife, cousin, sister and daughter at the same time. He always chose the most violent and direct option, even when diplomacy might have prevailed. If I had brought a leash for him, perhaps Prospero might not been destroyed,and the handful of innocents on the wretched rock might have lived.”
VII “I admire Dorn for his refusal to compromise his ideals, his honesty and his zeal. I wish I shared his idealism. But his refusal to compromise is his greatest weakness. He is more stubborn than a mule. He would rather win a moral victory and lose the tactical war than make a hard or dishonorable decision that keep you up at night. In addition he will not accept that Arlette will not let him fortify the Tranquil Courts.”
VII “Konrad Curze refused to accept help for dealing with his visions dammed him. He saw only one way to bring justice, through fear. The Night Lords were a necessary evil, but under him they became nothing but a band of criminals, He claimed to be a bringer of justice. A rather bold claim when one skinned men, women, and children alive.”
IX. “Sanguinus was compassionate and empathetic, but he never saw humans as people, he treated them like pets. For all his humiltiy, he basked in thier admiration like a tanner in the sun, Some part of him he refuses to admit enjoy’s how they view him He was too idealistic, and like Dorn refused to compromise on his ideals when it would be necessary. He was also surprisingly short tempered and hateful on occasion. I’m not sure if he knew this, but to some of the Silent Sisterhood, he came off as Misogynist.”
X “ Ferrus Mannus was incredibly short tempered. For all his and his legion’s cold-hearted and automata like behavior, he emotions collared him and kept him on his knees like a slave. He said he would purge the silver from his hand and ban the voluntary cybernetics of the Iron Tenth when the Great Crusade was done, yet if he had the strength he boasted so much of, he would have done it already. if he was logical as he claimed to be, he would not have died on Isstvan V.”
XII. “Although Angron would not accept it, I pity him. The Emperor should have let him die. The Butcher’s Nails have stolen any chance he had for a happy life, Yet the Butcher’s Nails does not excuse forcing them to be implanted them in his men.”
XIII “ Roboute is a statesman second only to Malcador. What he has done with Ultramar is nothing but remarkable. However, his obsession with control and efficiency, and his idealism, means everything must conform. Everything must be right or it will all fall apart. He cares for mortals, but like Sanguinius he believes he is their better and knows what’s best for them. Like the Lion, he demanded respect and obedience, and while he did earn it from his subordinates, like his brother, he had scorn for those who disagreed with his vision and banished them from his presence like the nobleman he denied he was. One can look no further than the 22nd chapter of the Ultramarines. These men are Destroyer’s and primarily Terrans from the old XIIIth legion. Many of their number also come from Ultramar and their Chapter Master is from the 500 Worlds. Yet the 22nd has a distinctive and unique culture that makes them stand out among the XIIIth ad other legion’s Destroyer Corps. Gulliman has made his dislike of Destroyer’s weaponry well known and their culture does not fit into his idealized view of his Legion , so he keep them at arms length like a red-headed stepchild. “
XIV. “Mortarion’s dislike towards Psykers, while justified due to the abuse of his foster father and the suffering he inflicted on him and the people of Barbarus, does not excuse his blind and irrational hatred for all of them. In addition, he lavished his affection on the legionaries from Barbarus and disbanded the Librarius of his legion. This made the former Librarians feel like illegitimate children. Mortarion was a prideful as Fulgrim, and could not accept the fact the Emperor had to save his life. When Mortarion spat on his oaths, he became the very thing he and the old XIVth legion swore to destroy, a tyrant with a callous disregard for life.”
XV “Magnus was arrogant. He believed himself superior to his brothers because of his abilities. He was a glutton for knowledge, but for all of his knowledge, Magnus was not very wise, and in his folly, dammed our entire species.”
XVI “ Horus… *sighs and takes a swig of hot chocolate* As much as I hate to admit it and as much as I tried to turn a blind eye to it, Horus was arrogant and acted like a spoiled brat. For all his tactical brilliance, for all his humor and kindness, He graved glory and adoration not for his Legion or for humanity, but for himself. Like Fulgrim, he wished all to bask in his glory and sing his praises. Horus wanted statues of himself, wanted people to prostrate themselves before him. He wanted their affection and love and to say “Yes Horus you are so brilliant what would we do without you.”
An old quote came to me regarding Horus Lupercal. “Veni Vidi Vici” Horus Came, he saw galaxy and humanity, and wished to conquer it. First for the Emperor, now for himself and his sick desires,”
XVII Lorgar is complicated. Arlette and I advised to Emperor to be merciful, when He censured him After the II and XI, I could not bear to slay another one of His children, and Lorgar’s transgression was nothing compared to the horrors the II and XI wrought on humanity. And I sympathized, with him not wishing to be a warrior, to try and be something besides another warlord. After all, when the crusade ended, and if Emperor’s safety could be absolutely guaranteed for eternity, i would live in a cave high in Himalzia with sheep for food and company and indulge in falconry and blacksmithing and toymaking and compose philosophical treaties. I could venture down from my solitude and strike down injustice and distribute candy and toys to children.
I was a dammed fool.
Like Leman, he was so changeable. He was like a child’s bouncy ball. Except he was loyal and devout in a misguided way, and than wicked, traitorous and spiteful, burning works and unleashing damnation with a smile on his face.
Lorgar had such faith in Emperor, he deified him, raised statues and built church’s all for Him. Now he is devoted to the Primordial Annihilator and will do anything to please his gods.
If only he had such faith in Humanity.
XVIII “ Vulkan’s Promethean Creed is an admirable philosophy. He had a heart bigger than an Ordinatus and kindness, compassion and smiling all came so easily to him. I envy him for his effortless kindness. Kindness, compassion and smiling are all things the Ten Thousand must hone as much as our skills in assassination and bladework.
Yet that compassion in his greatest weakness, Vulkan is not a warrior, he is a builder, a worker ant defending his anthill out of love. A blacksmith who forged all his creation but his weapons with pride.”
XIX “ Corax’s goal of liberating those in bondage is an admirable goal. Yet for all his time spend hiding in shadows, he failed to recognize necessary evils. On a personal note, I believe this character flaw led to his Terran legionaries meeting an ignoble end.”
XX The Alpha Legion began as a hammer in the shadow, another necessary evil. Yet when Alpharius took control, they became a twisted serpent. The old Christian devil in the form of a Hydra. Alpharius was a glutton for complicated plots and schemes. He is intoxicated on suffering and disorder. He is like Horus in the regard that all must know they were outsmarted by him. All most know that as soon as they sat down at the Regicide table with him, they were played like a damn fiddle.”
Any complaint’s about the Emperor, I shall keep to myself.
Arlette and I may have our disagreements, but we have each other’s back.
The only custodian I can complain about is Diocletion. He is quite frankly, a Dick. Empathy and compassion are skills he must learn. Time with the Ligo Aetos and humanity itself will be his teacher. “