Requested By: @jasssra
Hey, your writing is amazing! I was wondering if you can write a Peter Parker imagine where he is dating Starks daughter and they’ve been together for a while but he then cheats on her with Michele and it breaks her heart. Thanks! :)
Like usual, I have a song to go with the imagine, so if you’d like to listen click here
Also the song influenced the title of the imagine.
Pairing: Peter Parker x Reader
Description: You and Peter met when he was introduced into the Avengers, you both started hanging out a lot and then you started dating. Tony didn’t like the idea of you dating him, but eventually approved, but said there would be consequences if he broke your heart. Something he never thought he’d have to do.
Warnings: It’s just really sad and emotional
Word Count: 2,919
A/N: Okay I’m not gonna lie but my hands were full on shaking the entire time I was writing this because I got so into it?? I was getting super emotional and angry while writing and listening to Ke$ha’s new song Praying. Also, can we just talk about her new song though? There is so much emotion and power in it and I genuinely love it so much. This might be why I put so much emotion into this or because I’ve kinda gone through a relationship like this so I know how it feels in a way?? I dunno, read at your own risk because you will be hit with strong feels.
“Everyone, I would like to introduce a new member to the team, this is Peter Parker, aka the Spider-Man.” Tony smiled proudly, patting Peter on the back who looked nervous as hell.
“H-Hey everyone.” He waved awkwardly, making everyone chuckle at his hesitance.
“Well don’t just stand here, go mingle.” Tony motioned for him to go start up conversations with Steve and Natasha, while he went to talk to Wanda and Clint.
“So how old are you kid?” Steve smiled, observing his features, he looked kind of young to be on the team.
“I- uh- I’m fifteen.” Peter stammered, shifting his weight on his legs awkwardly, he hated that he couldn’t talk normally.
“Stark says you’re the Spider-Man?” Natasha smiled, looking at Peter who nodded slightly.
“Y-Yeah I am.” He gave a slight smile, rubbing the back of his neck anxiously.
“Hey, it will be okay, I know everything is new at first and a bit frightening especially for how young you are, but trust me, you’re going to fit in nicely.” Steve smiled, patting Peter on the shoulder, before disappearing into another room with Natasha.
Peter stood there awkwardly, he didn’t know where to go, or where he was even allowed to go.
He decided to go look for Tony, but bumped into someone right as he turned around.
“Ah, -Shit I’m so sorry I-” Peter stammered, his eyes widening seeing you standing in front of him.
“It’s cool, I always run into people somehow.” You laughed, shrugging your shoulders before moving around him.
Peter stared at you, his expression showing clear confusion written all over it.
You opened the fridge, grabbing a bottle of water, feeling his eyes burning holes into your back.
“Is there a reason you’re staring at me newbie?” You spoke opening the bottle without even looking at him.
“I uh- I mean- How did you- Uhm..” Peter stuttered, mentally face palming himself for being an idiot.
“I’m just messing with you.” You laughed, turning around to see his face flushed with embarrassment.
“Y-Yeah, right.” Peter nodded, trying to act unphased, but you and him both knew he couldn’t hide anything.
“What’s your name?” You asked, propping yourself up on the counter, swinging your legs back n’ forth.
“P-Parker Peter, -I mean, P-Peter Parker. Peter Parker.” He stuttered, making you laugh quietly, before he clearly managed to say his name.
He gave you a nervous smile, which you returned with a smile back.
You jumped off the counter, walking up to him.
“Y/N, Y/N Stark.” You grinned, patting his cheek before walking out of the kitchen, leaving a wide-eyed Peter.
Weeks after being introduced to the Avengers, Peter started fitting in really well, you even started hanging out with him more, doing homework together or just sitting outside, watching the sky change from day to night.
It was peaceful, something you craved to have, mainly since your life was far from normal.
“Y/N, do you ever wonder what’s out there?” Peter asked you one night, you two were sitting out on the balcony, staring up at the night sky, stars twinkling before you.
“I used to, but my dad blew it up.” You laughed, turning to look at Peter who’s eyes were wide with shock.
You laughed even more once you told him the entire story, of how your dad and the Avengers protected New York from Loki and his army of space aliens, and how he sent a nuke into outer space and blew up the alien ship.
Peter’s face was priceless after that, he told you how he got his powers, and how he could stop a bus with his own bare hands.
You two bonded a lot that night, you both kept growing closer and closer.
A few months had gone by and you were walking into your dads office, you were going to break the news you and Peter had started dating.
“Hey dad, you got a minute?” You smiled, peaking inside the room, seeing him smile and wave you in.
“Sure thing kiddo, what’s up?” Tony smiled, but it slowly faltered, seeing your anxious expression.
“I uh- I have to tell you something..” You twiddled with your hands nervously, feeling his intense stare on you.
“Peter and I.. We’re kind of dating now? But it’s okay dad, he’s really sweet and I know he wouldn’t hurt me.” You gave a small smile, seeing your dads face become serious.
“Y/N, he’s a teenaged boy, they’re unpredictable, I should know, I was one years ago.” Tony sighed, rubbing his face with his hands.
“I don’t like the fact you two are dating, but give me some time to get used to it okay?” He saw your eyes light up a bit, making him give you a small smile.
“Thanks dad.” You replied weakly, turning to leave, but he put his hand up in a stopping matter.
“But if he does break your heart, there will be consequences.” Tony spoke sternly, making you nod rapidly.
“I know, thank you.” You smiled, before leaving his office, leaving Tony to think over everything.
Weeks passed, soon months, then a year, and you and Peter couldn’t have been happier.
You two were what they called in school “couple goals” which made you laugh every time you heard someone say you and Peter were.
Everything was great, you felt like a normal person in high school, with high school friends.
You were walking to lunch with Liz, you had been helping her with homecoming decorations.
“So, can you come over later to go over a few things for homecoming?” Liz asked you, looping her arm within yours.
“Of course.” You replied, looking around the hallway before entering the cafeteria.
You were talking to Liz, before you noticed how she was staring at something else.
“Y/N, I think we should go do some homecoming prep work.” She tried to turn you around but you refused, but you wished you would have listened.
There sat Ned, Peter and Michelle, at your lunch table, but Peter and Michelle were holding hands, laughing over a stupid joke.
And then it happened, the thing that broke your heart.
Your mouth dropped open, you were stunned, how could the sweet innocent boy you met over a year ago do this to you?
Tears welled up in your eyes, but you refused to let them spill.
You felt your breathing start to become rapid, the amount of emotions rushing through you was too much to control.
You walked over to the table, acting as if you hadn’t seen anything, sitting down next to Ned.
“Hey Y/N.” Peter smiled, but you didn’t return the friendly gesture.
“Are you alright Y/N?” Michelle asked, seeing your stiff posture.
“I will be.” You replied angrily, grabbing Peter’s drink, before dumping it on his head.
He sat there baffled, before looking up at you and seeing your face flushed, eyes red.
“If you were going to cheat on me, the least you could have done was break up with me, I would of understood.” You choked out, before grabbing Ned’s drink and dumping it on Peter’s head again.
“I never want to speak to you again.” You glared at him, before backing away from the table.
“Y/N, wait! Please! I can explain!” Peter ran after you, catching your arm.
“Don’t touch me!” You yelled, making people look over at you both.
“You betrayed me, how could you?” You shouted, his shoulders slumping, avoiding your eyes.
“You’re an asshole Peter Parker.” You bit your lip, trying to get it to stop quivering.
“Y/N, please..” Peter pleaded, looking up at you through his wet hair.
You shook your head, a few tears slipping down your cheeks.
“Never speak to me again, in fact, I never want to see you again Peter.” You backed away from him, Liz wrapping her arms around you before dragging you off.
She gave Peter a look over her shoulder, which crushed Peter even more, he really screwed up.
He turned around, but noticed everyone was looking at him in pure shock and anger.
“Nice going Penis Parker!” Flash shouted, which made everyone else agree with him.
This was the longest day of Peter’s life.
Back at the Avengers headquarters, you rushed into the building, slamming the door behind you.
“Whoa hey what’s wrong Y/N?” Steve stood up, glancing at Natasha who looked equally as concerned.
Tears were streaming down your cheeks, you slowly looked up at the two, their expressions changing from concern to anger.
“H-He cheated on me.” You spoke in a whisper, your voice wavering as you stood there, your heart crumbling even more.
“No he didn’t, there’s no way.” Natasha shook her head in disbelief, looking at Steve who looked pissed as hell.
Steve pulled you into a hug, you let out a few sobs, before going to your room.
You sat there on your bed, trying to figure out what you should do first, but a knock on your door pulled you out of your thoughts.
“Hey kiddo..” Tony walked in, his heart breaking at the sight of you.
“Hey dad.” You smiled weakly, wiping your cheeks from the tears.
Tony walked over to you, pulling you into a side hug, and before you knew it, you were breaking down, letting out every emotion you had been bottling up.
Tony hated this feeling, he hated seeing you so broken, and he was one to keep his word, there would be consequences.
You soon had found out Tony had taken Peter’s Spider-Man suit from him, he told Peter he had wanted him to be better, and that if he was nothing without the suit then he just shouldn’t have it.
A part of you was sad for him, but at the same time you didn’t have a single care in the world.
Oh sometimes I pray for you at night,
Someday, maybe you’ll see the light.
A few weeks had gone by since your breakup with Peter, you had gotten rid of about everything he had given you, except a box of his belongings that you needed to deliver.
You hadn’t seen him since that day in the cafeteria, so you knew it was going to be a bit awkward.
Tony had kicked him out of the Avengers building, so you had to travel to his apartment.
You knocked on his door, awkwardly waiting for someone to answer.
When Peter opened the door, seeing you was a shock, he wasn’t expecting that at all.
“Y/N.” He breathed out, making your eyes snap up to meet his.
“I have the rest of your stuff.” You handed him the box, then crossed your arms.
“Uh, um, thanks.” Peter mumbled, setting the box on the ground.
“Well, bye.” You glanced at him one more time before walking down the hallway, only to be stopped by him.
“Y/N, please let me explain.” Peter pleaded once again, making you stop and turn around.
“No let me.” You glared at him, making his eyes widen a bit.
“You almost had me fooled, but after everything you’ve done, I can thank you for how strong I have become.” You ran your fingers through your hair, trying to choose your words carefully.
“Y/N, I never meant to hurt you.” Peter tried to intervene but you held your hand up.
“You put me through hell, I had to learn how to fight for myself, and we both know all the truth I could tell, I’ll just say this is I wish you farewell.” You gave a small smile, before turning around and walking down the hallway.
There was no way you were going to give into his bullshit speech about how he messed up and wished he never did what he did.
Peter watched you walk away from him, his heart breaking into pieces.
But he wasn’t going to give up without a fight.
You were sitting at the table in the kitchen, listening to your music.
I hope you’re somewhere prayin’, prayin’,
I hope your soul is changin’, changin’,
I hope you find your peace,
Falling on your knees, prayin’.
You couldn’t help but hum along to the words, you felt connected to the song in so many ways.
Steve and Natasha were in the living room, hearing you sing along to the song, their hearts breaking a bit.
Peter had really hurt you, and it was their job also to protect you.
You were singing along to the song when someone walked up to you, you glanced up only to be met by Peter.
“Y/N, please just let me talk to you.” Peter begged, making you roll your eyes in annoyance.
Can’t he just leave you alone?
“What’s there to talk about? You cheated on me, the end.” You stated bluntly, making Peter cringe.
“Nothing really happened between Michelle and I, it was a dare.” Peter tried to explain, but you were already over it.
“I’m proud of who I am, I don’t need you, I found strength I’ve never known.” You sighed, looking at Peter who was still stunned.
“Peter, you need to leave.” You motioned towards the door, he nodded slowly, knowing it was no use, he had really messed up the best thing in his life.
Oh, some say, in life, you’re gonna get what you give,
But some things only God can forgive,
I hope you’re somewhere prayin’, prayin’,
I hope your soul is changin’, changin’,
I hope you find your peace,
Falling on your knees,