History Part 2~ Theo Raeken Imagine
A/N: I can’t believe you guys liked the first one so much! Thank you so much for reading it and requesting a part 2! I hope you enjoy this one as much as you did the first one.
Requested: Yes. Yes. It was.
Prompt: You haven’t seen Theo since he was sent to hell and now he’s back but you have a new guy in your life. Yet that won’t stop Theo from winning you back.
“With that look came his oh so signature smirk and 3 words that made my breathe hitch. “Not for long.” and with that, he turned and retreated into the darkness”
Here I was, one week later, standing in the middle of an empty classroom with Theo right in front of me. He was looking at me, like I was the only thing in the world he ever cared about and quite honestly I was looking at him the exact same way. All I wanted to do was run into his arms, forget the world around us, and just run away together. Yet, before I could act on my rash decisions, Theo opened his mouth to speak.
“I’ve been trying to get you alone all week, but your guard dog just wouldn’t leave your side.” I shook my head, letting out a small laugh. It was true Nathan was being extra clingy this week but that’s only because he feels threatened. What else would any sane person do when Theo Raeken shows up, out of nowhere, threating to take the girl you love away from you. I looked at Theo. “Yea. Well, he just doesn’t want to lose me.” “I don’t blame him.” He looked sad, which, in turn, made me feel guilty. I shouldn’t have moved on, I should have waited for him, I should have had more faith that he would come back to me. I looked at the ground and whispered quietly. “I’m sorry Theo.” He instantly walked towards me, stopping when his feet touched mine. With one hand he gently grasped my waist while using the other to lift up my head, ever so delicately. “Hey. It’s not your fault. None of this is. It’s mine. If I hadn’t been such an asshole then Scott wouldn’t have felt the need to send me away.” The more regret and sadness I saw in his eyes, the guiltier I felt. “I know, but I shouldn’t have started dating someone else. I should have waited for you Theo. I should have believed that you would have found a way to come back to me. I’m so sorry. If it wasn’t for me this wouldn’t be so complicated.” That’s when the tears started to flow endlessly down my flaming cheeks as Theo shh’d me and pull me closer into his chest. “Y/N. Princess. It’s okay. I would’ve have wanted you to move on. To find someone that makes you happy. I didn’t know if I was going to get out. No one did.” He rubbed my back soothingly as I continued to cry silently on his chest. “The question here, is does he make you happy Y/N. If he does then I will leave you alone, and let you be happy with him.”.
I looked up at Theo. Did Nathan make me happy? Sure, we had great times together and I always seemed to find myself laughing when I am with him. But he didn’t make me as happy as Theo did. I don’t think anyone could make me that happy. There wasn’t enough time to tell Theo the truth, as Scott comes barging into the classroom, looking extremely out of breath. “I don’t mean to break up this reunion, but Nathan is coming down the hall, looking for you Y/N.” Theo looked down at me and placed a soft gently kiss on my forehead. “Let me know when you have an answer”. With that he disappeared with Scott out into the hallway and I knew exactly what I had to do.
Within in minutes, Nathan was entering the classroom, looking directly at me. “Y/N? What are you doing in here?” I sighed softly and motioned for him to sit in the desk next to me. He did as I asked and I looked at him, trying to muster up the courage to do this. “Nathan. I care about you, and I know you care about me, but-” He stopped me by standing up and taking a few steps back. “Are you breaking up with me? For him?” I tried to reach for him, but every step I took towards him, he took two more back. “Look Nathan. It’s nothing you did. Theo’s my guy. He’s the guy I’m in love with and I will always be in love with him. God Nathan, you’re perfect in every aspect that comes in the boyfriend category, but Theo is perfect for me.” He simply shook his head. “Why did you date me if you were just going to go back to him?” I thought about it for a moment and then exhaled. “Honestly, I didn’t think he was coming back. No one did. I thought that you could be the guy who makes me forget Theo, in every way. But he’s back now, and it wouldn’t be fair to you or to myself to continue this relationship with you if I still love him.” Nathan nodded and exited with a soft “See you around Y/N”.
With that out of the way, I picked up my bag off the floor and ran for the hallway. I had to find him. I had to tell him. Searching in every classroom and every hallway, I finally spotted him standing next to my locker. I stopped in my tracks and smiled as we locked eyes. In seconds, I was running as fast as I could into his arms. He caught me effortlessly pulling me close to him as I wrapped my legs around his waist and my arms around his neck. “It’s you. It’s always been you and it will always be you. I love you Theo Raeken.” I’ve never seen him smile that wide and his eyes twinkle so bright. “I’ve waited 6 long months to hear those words again. I love you Y/N Y/L/N.” With those words being said, I crashed my lips onto his and promised myself that I would never let anyone take him away from me ever again.