Imagine Sam leaving you and Dean to look for John in California
A/N: This takes place S1E11, Scarecrow.
Dean x Sister!Reader Sam x Sister!Reader
“Yeah, it’s called being a good son!” Dean yelled at Sam. The two of them had been arguing ever since John called this morning; you had stayed out of it for the most part, still ticked off at both of them. You were listening to your iPod when you saw the front passenger door swing open. Sam got out of the car and glanced at you for a moment before he slammed the door. Looking up at Dean you saw him reach for the handle of the door, the sign that he was going to follow Sam out of the car.
You remained in the backseat, just hoping this would blow over so you guys could move on to the hunt. To be honest you weren’t sure how much more of this sibling drama you could take.
“You’re a selfish bastard,
you know that? You just do whatever you want. Don’t care what anybody thinks.” You heard Dean say from outside of the impala.
“Is that what you really think?” Sam questioned his brother.
“Yeah, it is.” Dean stated like it was a fact.
“Then this selfish bastard is going to California.” Sam replied as he grabbed the last of his belongings from the trunk. With those words you swung the door open and stumbled out of the car. You were still furious with your brothers; Dean had kept a secret from you your entire life and Sam had ditched you when he went to Stanford, however the thought of either of them leaving you right now scared you to death.
You weren’t sure if you were ever going to see your dad again and you didn’t want to risk losing either of them.
“Come on, you’re not serious!” Dean exclaimed.
“I am serious!” Sam said back with as much anger in his voice.
“It’s the middle of the night, I’m taking off! I will
leave your ass, you hear me!” Dean shouted at Sam.
“That’s what I want you to do!” Sam said as he turned around and raised his arms in the air at Dean. Only when he turned around he saw you standing behind Dean with a hurt expression on your face. He stopped for a moment as he noticed there were unshed tears in your eyes.
“Please don’t go Sammy.” You said in a quiet voice that he almost couldn’t hear, “Not again.”
“I’m sorry Y/N/N but I-” Sam started but you just shook your head and returned to the backseat of the impala. Dean and Sam made eye contact for a moment before Sam broke it and continued down the empty road.
Dean let out a frustrated sigh before slamming the impala’s trunk and opening the driver’s side door, “Goodbye Sam.” He said as he got into the driver’s seat and started the car back up.
“Y/N?” Dean asked quietly as if he would scare you if he spoke too loud.
“Not now Dean.” You replied in a rough voice from trying to hold back the tears.
Dean let out a sigh but let it go, knowing that pushing you was a bad idea. He continued down the road to the destination that John had given you guys. After about an hour of silence Dean thought he was going to lose his mind, that was until your soft voice cut through the silence.
“Please don’t ever leave me Dean. Sam did, Dad did, now Sam left again. I just-” You said as you took in a shaky breath, alerting Dean of your tears, “Just don’t ever leave me.”
Tags below the cut