Haruhi : When you woke up panting and crying, at first she would be confused about what was happening. Being suddenly woken up left her a little cranky. However, once she realized how upset you were, she would immediately come to your side and ask you to tell her what happened. She would also talk about stories from when she had bad nightmares, so that you wouldn’t feel ashamed about it. After you calmed down she would lay down with you, snuggling up and rubbing her hand up your arm or down your back in a soothing pattern.
Kaoru : He actually woke up before you did. That was mostly due to the fact that you were moving around so much and then nailed him in the stomach with your foot. He’d shake you gently, whispering your name over and over until you were awake. When you suddenly sat up and hugged him tightly, he didn’t object or ask questions. He simply laid you back down, holding you close, rubbing your hair and whispering sweet nothings into your ear until you fell asleep again.
(sorry, the gif is really big, just keep scrolling down)
Hikaru : He knew that you were awake, he just didn’t know why, and frankly, he didn’t care. He wanted to fall back asleep, and whatever you needed could wait until the morning. It wasn’t until a few minutes later, when you shook him awake that he finally opened his eyes. He was about to yell until he saw that you had tears in your eyes. Of course, him being the stubborn person he is, he only pulled you into a hug, and continued to tell you to go back to sleep so that he wouldn’t be tired the next day.
“Come on, go back to sleep, idiot.”
Though on the inside, he was extremely worried about you.
Tamaki : He had known immediately that something was wrong when he heard a small whimper from your side of the bed. You weren’t one to wake up during the night, especially after a long day at school. He would turn around slowly, and wrap his arms around you; nuzzling his nose into the back of your head.
“Are you okay princess?”
He would ask you what had happened, but wouldn’t push you if weren’t ready yet. He would try to ask again in the morning, just to make sure you were okay. In the meantime, he would just whisper compliments to you, and move around so that you were comfortable, but as close to him as possible.
Kyoya : He would still be awake in another room when you came padding into the room. He would wait a minute for you to say something, but after a moment, he would turn around to see you standing in the doorway in a pitiful state. He would open his mouth to say something, but before he could, you ran towards him and sat on his lap. He would let you cry for a minute, kissing your head and rubbing his arms up and down your back. He would take a more logical approach, asking you to tell him just what happened in your dream, or maybe take you to the kitchen to make you a warm glass of milk, and hold you in his arms until you fell into a peaceful slumber. He would take you back to the room, lay down with you in bed, and fall asleep with you in his arms.
Morinozuka : You had already been in his arms when you woke up. You had already forgotten what the dream was about, just that it was scaring you a lot. Mori, of course, with his super ninja-like skills, would have already woken up, and known that you were awake too. He would grunt to tell you he was awake, and when you just smiled up towards him, he knew something was wrong. That wasn’t your smile. Instead of commenting, he would tighten his arms around you. He may even hum a song for you. Anything that would give you peace of mind, he would do, until you eventually fell back asleep with him.
Mitsukuni : When Mitsukuni knows what happened, he would break out into tears as well. Most likely even more than you already were.
“Ahhh, (Y/N)! I’m sorry I couldn’t protect you from the monsters! I promise I’ll become stronger so I can beat them next time, okay?”
He would be crying for quite a bit, and you would completely forget about your dream, instead trying to distract your now hysterical boyfriend. You would try to find something to distract him, but only got a response when you suggested you guys have an early-morning movie marathon with lots of sweet treats. You wouldn’t be getting anymore sleep that night, but you had found one of the greatest cures for a nightmare.