Jason is the kind of older brother who will pick you up and carry you into the kitchen while you scream “put me down put me down put me down” and drop you into the garbage can saying “okay I’ll put you down” and Damian is the kind of younger brother who falls victim to this multiple times
I almost named this theory “Return of the Mother of all Theories” but I thought “The Mother Dearest Theory” would probably be more fitting considering what this is going to be about. If you haven’t caught on by now with the name, let me fill you in… This theory is going to outline why I think Mary Drake is possibly the new A.D.
I KNOW I KNOW I KNOW “But Rachel, what about Melissa/Twin/Any other possible character?” Simply because… There are too many things that point to Mary that I just can’t ignore anymore, and in true PLL fashion there is possibly Hitchcock involved.
From the very beginning when Mary was introduced, she rubbed me the wrong way, something about the way she talks and carries herself screams psychopath to me (and trust me… I’ve spent most of my life researching them.) What she says doesn’t necessarily coincide with what she does, and things have been gradually building up to the point I can’t ignore the signs anymore.
So, let’s start at the beginning so to speak… I’m going to talk about the twins from the Halloween story. We all know how it goes, one twin gets jealous of what the other twin had and then one twin stabs the other. Mary stabbed Jessica, Mary went to Radley, Mary met Pastor Ted and had Charlotte, Mary pretended to be Jessica, Mary got pregnant with Spencer by pretending to be Jessica with Peter (which is the huge secret Jessica and Peter had that they had a deal with), and Mary is batshit fucking crazy.
Also let me ask this question, did we all just up and fucking forget this happened?
How the hell did we forget that Mary dressed up as her dead sister to scare Alison (AND PUT HER IN THE HOSPITAL) and for that matter… How in the bloody hell did Mary know what Jessica was buried in if she wasn’t there burying herself. And for that matter, it would mean she ways the one who not only buried her- but she was there when Alison was buried as well. If you remember in season 5 when Alison came back to rosewood and Jessica’s body was found, Alison got a video of her mother being buried with a text attached saying “I buried her the same way I watched her bury you.”
To be fairly truthful whether Mary stabbed Jessica doesn’t matter, the facts are that Mary spent a lot of time in Radley where (like I’ve outlined multiple times in other theories and it actually comes into play later…) Mary assumes Jessica’s identity which confirms not only that she was the mother Bethany was talking about and the “is it like mother like daughter?” Was referring to Mary and Charlotte and not Jessica and Alison, which is confirmed by the flashback of Jessica screaming at Alison that Cece was at Radley calling herself Alison.
Now to my favorite part… The Hitchcock aspect. Does everyone remember that scene where Hanna was being tortured in the barn and she hallucinates that’s Spencer is there stroking her hair and singing a song? (The same song and scene that they recreated with Mary and Spencer in the 7x10)
Yeah that’s not a coincidence, look at Mary’s history… She assumes Jessica’s identity, she assumes Charlottes identity as A.D., she’s now assuming Spencer’s identity. Yes, my friends… PLL is pulling a reverse Psycho where Mother assumes the role of Norman instead of the other way around. Think about it, what’s the FIRST thing she does? Buy the lost woods, just as Norman Bates did with his mother and the bates motel. And just as Norman Bates assumed the identity of his mother, Mary seems to take the personality of her daughters on- becoming A.D. As Charlotte was A, and now becoming more caring, calm, and subdued like Spencer… Also people have been passing around this photo:
I’d like you to notice something, look at the make-up and body language of both the scene where Spencer’s with Hanna and this scene compared to Mary’s tea cup scene… That ISN’T Spencer in there… That’s Mary. Confirmed by the fact Andrea was wearing the EXACT dress she was wearing.
Also, since we know for sure Mary and Archer we’re working together (and that she was helping torture Alison) guess who the only other person was who knew about the barn? Yep. Mary. And what just happened last episode? Hanna getting locked in like she was back in the barn, considering Archer is dead… There’s really only one other person who knew. Mary.
Mary seems to have a pattern of assuming the identities of people she’s close with, so naturally that next step would be Spencer.
Mary showed up before Charlotte died and A.D. Was introduced just as Charlotte appeared once Mona lost the game as A after season 2.
Mary bought the Lost Woods where Hanna was kidnapped and tortured. And for that very matter how in the living fresh hell did she get that money in the first place?
Mary was known to be working with Archer and we know for a fact whoever A.D. Is not only worked with Archer but knows the girls killed him.
We know for a fact that Mary was involved with everything because she LITERALLY SAYS TORTURING ALISON IS WHAT CHARLOTTE WOULD HAVE WANTED. Just like some antagonist I know of who seems to be targeting the girls because they think they had something to do with Charlotte’s death.
We also know Jessica had some sore of heart condition and trouble getting to sleep (as per her prescriptions) that I don’t know… Would probably coincide with a devastating childhood trauma involving her twin sister?
Which would only make Mary hate Jessica even MORE causing her to assume Jessica’s identity. “But she was in Radley!” Doesn’t it seem odd to anyone how the twin story was put in chronological order to where oddly a Radley sanitarium car shows up at the house the exact DAY the twin story is told?
This would also mean Charlotte, Mary, and Bethany were all in Radley at the same time and if that doesn’t scream trouble incoming I don’t know what does. This also brings me to the obvious blatant lie that Mary and Charlotte didn’t know each other. She literally called herself Cece Drake. The same last name. And Mary says with quite confidence “You’re the only man my daughter truly ever loved”
Side-note, whoever is revealed as Jessica’s killer could’ve possibly made the mistake of thinking they were killing Mary instead of Jessica, in which case you’d think it would throw the theory off course- but it actually doesn’t. It could’ve been Charlotte and she lied about it, it could’ve been someone who thought Jessica was Mary by mistake, it could’ve been Mary herself. But the signs point to Mary as being her killer, or at least being there as Jessica was being buried per her clothes a la zombie Jessica in 6x20.
Now as per why… Simple answer, Mary wants everything that she feels was taken from her. She wants the life that she feels was taken from her. She wants revenge for the daughter she lost. She wants revenge on the families who had what she always wanted.
As for Charlotte’s killer (If she’s dead at all…) I will tell you that you’d do well to watch Mona. Or even possibly someone who appears to be Mona. They’re going to bring in Melissa and Wren to make it appear as though they have something to do with it, revealing things that we’ve wondered about them for a long time…
And Melissa’s luggage bag handle may have been missing but I would like to remind you… Who paid off the mechanic and drove the huge truck that nearly ran over Emily to get it back?
I hope the theory was well worth the wait, it was good to get back in the theory game again.
You move into your new apartment, and discover Jonghyun and Jisoo, the adorable father-daughter duo across the hallway. It doesn’t hurt that Jonghyun is incredibly attractive.
“That’s the last one,” you said to yourself proudly, staring
down at the boxes that surrounded you. Pushing your hair back from your sweaty
face, you couldn’t help but nod, happy that you were finally moving in.
It was your last year of college, and you’d decided to move
into your own apartment. All of your friends had been busy on the day you’d
decided to move in, about a month before classes began, so you’d had to lug up
all your boxes of things and all the furniture yourself. It hadn’t been easy, but
you’d gotten it done.
Just as you were about to settle onto the floor, arms
splayed out, the doorbell rang. You groaned inwardly, hurrying to answer it.
“Hi.” Your breath caught as soon as you yanked open the
door. One of the most gorgeous guys you’d ever seen was standing there, smiling
slightly. He was dressed casually, jeans and a t-shirt, his black hair falling
into his eyes.
“Welcome!” A much higher-pitched, squeaky voice exclaimed.
Your eyes travelled down from the guy to the small figure clinging onto his
outstretched hand—a young girl, maybe 4 or 5, stood there, grinning widely. You
cooed mentally at how adorable she was, with slightly chubby cheeks, tiny hands
and a missing front tooth.
“We just wanted to welcome you to the neighborhood,” the guy
said gently with a small smile. You turned your attention back to him, and
couldn’t help but notice how nice his voice was. “Right, baby?” He glanced down
at the small girl, voice tender. Your heart was actually melting.
“Right!” The young girl nodded, shoving a container towards
you, “we baked you cookies!”
You smiled widely, crouching down so that you were eye-level
with the girl, “did you really? That’s awesome, you’re an angel! Thank you.”
The girl grinned again, revealing that missing tooth, “Daddy
almost started a fire.” You grinned at how cute she was, glancing back up at
the guy, who looked mildly embarrassed, but also used to the girl’s attitude.
“Thank you so much,”
you told the guy, container of cookies in hand, “I really appreciate the
gesture, I know you’re probably super busy, so thank you.”
“It’s no trouble,” the guy assured you with a smile, “We
were once the new people in the building, so if you ever need help, feel free
to ask, we’re right across the hall. I’m Jonghyun, and this is my daughter Jisoo.”
“I’m (y/n),” you replied, heart a puddle of goo over how
adorable Jisoo was and how incredibly perfect Jonghyun was. “Thank you again, I
really appreciate it.”
“Well, we’ll see you around,” Jonghyun said, and you nodded
quickly in agreement, “have a nice night.”
“I hope you have fun living here!” Jisoo smiled up at you,
making you smile back.
“Thank you, have a nice night as well!”
As you closed the door, you placed a hand over your pounding
heart. Jonghyun was actually perfect,
what the hell. He was incredibly handsome, kind, and he clearly cared a lot
about his daughter, who was also a total sweetheart.
Fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me fight me behind a dennys >:³c
So I’m traveling with Hancock and we stopped to drop off some junk at Starlight Drive-In. I take all the stuff I have Hancock carrying and become encumbered and slow but whatever ‘cause the workshop’s like five feet away.
Hancock, beautiful sinnamon roll that he is, immediately starts fretting. “Oh no, that’s too much! Here, give some back.”
A half-second later, faintly, from clear across the settlement, I hear MacCready screaming, “DON’T MAKE ME CARRY ALL THAT WORTHLESS CRAP!”