Betrayal (Reggie x Reader)
Request: Can you write a imagine where Chuck Clayton from Riverdale want to go on a date with the reader but ahe always reject him and then he just write her name on the playbook and her boyfriend Reggie sees it and they have a huge fight? It’s up to you if they will break up after the fight or get together
Word Count: 1,683
“Still a no Y/L/N?” Chuck asked as he leaned over your lunch table.
“Yes and always will be” You said with a glare. Poor Chuck couldn’t take a hint. He had been asking you out for months now even with knowing you were seeing Reggie but that didn’t seem to phase him. Your answer was always no but he just kept pushing, to him it was like the end of the world that a girl was saying no.
“Come now babe, we both know that I’m better than Reggie”
“Are we talking about the same person? Because I don’t think so” You huffed. He was annoying you and it didn’t help that all of the football teams eyes were on you two. A glare came across Chuck face as the team started to laugh at his failed attempt once again. You still didn’t understand how they could go behind Reggie back and let something like this happen. Didn’t they care at all that their captain was trying to take away one of their girls.
“Why are you such a bitch?” Chuck let out, anger clearly showing on his face now as he eyebrows were furrowed and his mouth was in a straight firm line. He was getting sick of rejection.
“You heard me the first time. All I ever have been is nice to you and this is how you replay me? Get off your high horse and see what’s in front of you” Chuck snapped as he crossed his arm, earning some looks from others in the room. This was getting bigger then any other interaction that you guys have had before.
“Maybe if you weren’t such a dick and a fuckboy I could consider but I guess we both aren’t getting what we want are we?” You stood up from your seat maybe just a little to fast as your water bottle knocked over and spilled right into Chuck’s lap.
“You bitch” He yelled as he stood up, his navy pants now rocking a shade of black. You didn’t feel a bit of guilt as people throughout the cafeteria started to laugh. It’s not like you meant for it to happened but you didn’t regret it either. “You’ll pay for this Y/L/N, just wait” With that Chuck stomped out of the room full of laughing people. You didn’t think anything of his words at the time as Chuck was a guy that mostly talk and never do but boy were you wrong. You just didn’t expect it to be this.
When Chuck walked out of the cafeteria he knew what to do. You may have been denying him to his face but that could only be for the public eye as you were pretty much with Reggie. He knew that’s how others could see it even if it wasn’t the truth. So Chuck went to the only thing he cared about. The only thing that truly matter among the football team and the guys in this school. When he was done with it he couldn’t wait to see your reaction but more importantly Reggie because at the end of the day Chuck Clayton always got what he wanted.
"Go Moose!“ All of the locker room was chanting and cheering. Moose had just revealed the latest details of his most recent hook up and the team couldn’t be more excited. This meant one thing and that it was time to mark it down.
“Here” One of the guys said as he threw the book into Reggie’s lap. He was Moose best friend so he might as well do the honours. Reggie grinned and flipped open the book, flicking threw all of the filled out pages of different girls names and their points. This was nothing knew as they had did it many times before but something caught Reggie eye as he went to right down Moose new score. It was Chuck’s name but more importantly your name was right beside it.
Chuck- Y/N Y/L/N (8) Girl who always said no finally said yes or more like “More Chuck”
Reggie’s eye shotted up from the page, going straight for Chucks slight.
“You slept with my girlfriend?” Reggie asked, standing up from his seat from the bench. Throwing the book to the side no longer caring about Moose’s hook up.
Chuck laughed and spread a smirk across his face.
“What can I say Reg? No one ever says no to Chuck Clayton not even your precious girlfriend.”
“My girlfriend really?” Reggie shouted not knowing what to do. How could his friend betray him like that but most importantly how could you? He loved you but was he not enough? “I can’t believe you did this” Reggie was pulling the ends of his hair. He didn’t like this one bit and with the whole team staring at the two he couldn’t help but feel as something was missing. Why would you even sleep with Chuck?
“You couldn’t just leave one girl alone! You had to go after my girl” Reggie said still shouting. He was full of emotions and didn’t know what one to express. Chuck just shrugged his shoulders
“You know Reggie maybe if you treated her right she wouldn’t of came crawling into my arms”
“Go fuck yourself”
“Maybe I’ll get your girlfriend to do it” With that comment Reggie lunged towards Chuck ready to bounce on him. Anger was clearly the emotion that wanted to come out. Just when he was about to land a hit he was pulled back by Morse and one of his other teammates.
“Don’t, just go talk to your girl” Moose said not even glancing at Reggie his eye fully on Chuck knowing he had done something. Reggie just nodded his head and pulled away from the boys. He was in disbelief as he left the locker room to go in search of you to find out the truth but Reggie started to wonder as he made his way down the hallway if he really wanted to get to the bottom of it.
You glance up from your reading spot as you heard footsteps come closer.
“Hey Reg” You said quickly trying to put yourself stuff into your bookbag so you guys could go. You always sat down at one of the lunch tables and read or do homework when Reggie had practice. When Reggie didn’t answer you looked up.
“You alright?” You asked but you could see he really wasn’t. He looked angry and his fast heavy breathing was a dead giveaway that something wasn’t right. “Are you planning on saying anything or are you just going to stare at me?”
“Why did you sleep with Chuck?” Reggie blurted out which left you speechless. You just blinked at him not knowing what to say. All Reggie could do was stare at you with hard eyes but you could see the pain that he was masking.
“Wait what?” You asked not sure if you did hear him right, did he really think you of all people hook up with Chuck.
“You had sex with Chuck! Why? You’re my girlfriend, why did you feel the need to go cheat on me with one of my teammates. You could’ve just said if you didn’t feel this way”
“I never hook up with Chuck, where in the world did you hear that?” You pursued, Chuck had to get revenge some how and you thought this was it.
“It doesn’t matter” Reggie huffed
“That’s bullshit” You said as you stood up, crossing your arms you met eyes with Reggie. “So please enlighten me on where you heard this false news”
“Are you joking?”
“Well Chuck was lying wait now a book?” You were confused for a moment why would it be in a book.
“Just forget that part now”
“No! I want to know the truth. Chuck had been asking me out for weeks and I kept saying no, this have to be some kind of setup”
“Weeks?” Reggie shouted, he knew that Chuck had asked you once thanks to some of his teammates but he didn’t think it was a still ongoing since you guys were now dating. “Man” Reggie rubbed his face with his hands. This was news to him. “It’s a book my team has of some of our hookups and when I went to put one in for Moose I notice your name. Chuck put it there and you can say I wasn’t happy”
“I wouldn’t be either if I thought you cheated so” You didn’t know what else to say. It was all up to Reggie on how the rest of this all went. It was silence as Reggie process everything in his brain.
“Did you think I really cheated?” You whispered, out of the whole conversation that was the one thing that was bugging you. Reggie sighed then looked at you with a half smile
“No it just, the thought of you even sleeping with him made my blood boil, you are my girlfriend now and I just.. I love you. I can’t handle the thought of you loving someone else.
“Reggie” You let out as you walked closer to the tall boy, placing a hand on his cheek.
“I love you and I promise you that I didn’t sleep with Chuck, you can asked so many people and they will tell you that I can’t the kid”
“I’m sorry for accusing you”
“I understand why you did it, don’t worry” Reggie placed a soft kiss on your lips and held you in his arms. He was happy that you two were good but now the problem came with Chuck. His captain and someone who he thought was his friend lie to him and try to ruin his relationship. That didn’t sit well with Reggie and he knew something had to happened but right now he would enjoy this moment with you in his arms because even if your hair was all over the place with the wind there was no way anything could not make you look beautiful