The boys in: a slasher movie! (in which everyone dies)
so here’s something a little, uh, different…
Noctis: Noctis is making a run for it when the murderer snatches up Prompto and he’s forced to go back for him. He attempts to face off with the murderer one last time and manages to mortally wound him, but not without sustaining serious injuries. Dragging his broken body out of the killer’s hideout, Noctis makes it as far as the road before succumbing to his wounds.
Prompto: Almost makes it out with Noctis but at the last second the killer grabs him. Since Prompto is the nicest one he obviously needs to have the most heart wrenching death. Noctis goes back to try and help and finds Prompto on the floor bleeding out from his neck, struggling to breathe as blood bubbles up from his throat and trickles from the corners of his mouth.
Gladio: Gladio would go down first. He dies in a heroic attempt to fight off the killer while the other three boys try to get away. He manages to get a good stab in there, but of course, the bad guy is never truly dead the first time. As Gladio backs away from the seemingly lifeless body, the killer quickly gets up and stabs him in the chest. Realizing that wouldn’t be enough, the killer continues to stab him over and over until Gladio’s torso is reduced to nothing but bloody shreds.
Ignis: The character that should survive out of sheer resourcefulness and ability but ends up dying anyway. Ignis is the one who dies the most gruesome death. The murderer cuts him up into well sized pieces, starting from his feet and going up so he’d be forced to stay awake until he either passes out from pain or is decapitated. He’s the Recipeh now.