You could see on Ian’s face that the whole “skipped prom with two girls instead of just each other” story was such a lie

Ian: We didn’t go to our senior prom.

Anthony: Yeah we just went to Olive Garden with these two younger girls 

Everyone: awwwwww

Ian: *looking at Anthony questioningly* yeeeahhh…. 

Anthony: We were too cool for school prom!!!

Ian: ……yeah……. 

We all know thats not what really happened