I did a little study with the third grade class I was helping out with the other day.
First, I asked them what they thought of the current Nicktoons.
SpongeBob Squarepants and The Fairly OddParents got extremely positive reception amongst the kids (though they actually seem to prefer FOP)
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles was right behind the first two- a lot of the kids love it.
Sanjay and Craig was pretty mixed. A few kids liked it, some of them hated it, and the others thought it was just “okay”.
Nobody really cared about Rabbids Invasion.
As soon as I even said the word “Breadwinners”, I got a collective groan so loud that I felt like I was in a Peanuts special. Yeah, the kids REALLY hate that one.
None of the kids seemed interested in The Legend of Korra, but it also turned out that virtually none of these kids really watched Avatar: The Last Airbender, so it’s justified.
After I did that, I asked the kids what other Nicktoons they liked that I didn’t mention. Most of them seemed to really like:
Rugrats (Seemed to be the most popular) Hey Arnold! CatDog Invader Zim ChalkZone (I wasn’t sure how many kids would know this show since it ended when these kids were born and the repeats were on in early morning timeslots, but I came in wearing my Rudy t-shirt and a few of the kids knew who it was) The Adventures of Jimmy Neutron: Boy Genius (Second most popular next to Rugrats) My Life as a Teenage Robot Danny Phantom
How did they see these? For starters, just about all of them have Nicktoons. The others saw the other shows via older siblings or cousins.
After that, I decided to ask the kids what their favorite animated shows as a whole were (including non-Nick). The top five were:
5. My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic 4. Adventure Time 3. Phineas and Ferb 2. SpongeBob Squarepants 1. The Fairly OddParents
Honorable mentions went to The Powerpuff Girls and Animaniacs (remember that these kids all get Boomerang and The Hub, so they have easy rerun access)
Then I asked the kids what their least favorites were. The results were:
5. Any show made for preschoolers (please remember that these kids are eight years old) 4. Fish Hooks 3. Fanboy and Chum-Chum 2. Johnny Test 1. Breadwinners
Do you watch Great British Bake Off? I'm re-watching series 6, and Tamal is reminding me a bit of your Harry Potter, he just needs a pair of glasses. IDK, maybe in some sort of strange AU where Harry harnesses his years of cooking for the Dursleys and decides to turn it into something positive.