Brooke and Audrey were so out if character in the Halloween episode. They were literally trying to force Emma to be with Alex and have a one night stand. Audrey said “he could be way more fun that a tattoo” implying having sex with him. we’ve never seen her say anything like this in regards to Emma’s dating life si why starts now after kieran? Then we have Brooke telling her that she doesn’t need to know if full name to have fun (or something along those lines) and also to let her guard down on the dock to have a little fun. It’s like they completely forgot that her boyfriend turned out to be a killer who was torturing her and them and tried to frame her and her best friend for murder. She would have major trust issues after that that would take WAY longer than 8 months to get over. She clearly wasn’t even that in to Alex she’s hesitated to kiss him goodnight when he dropped her off after their date. Emma might have dated 3 guys (if you count Alex which I don’t really) and almost kissed Eli but she’s not a one night stand type of girl she’s only ever had sex with what she believed to be faithful boyfriends.