Dear Evan Hansen Reverse AU: Peanut Butter Cookies
It had been weeks since the funeral and it psychically hurt Jared to step closer to Evan’s house. Every step weighed down like a cement brick into he found himself at the front door. Mustering up the courage he knocked on the door. For a moment he thought the house was empty and was getting ready to turn and leave when the door opened. There stood Heidi Hansen with a surprisingly bright smile. She looked very different from a from the last time he saw her.
“Jared!” He was surprised when she went to hug him. He awkwardly accepted.
“Hi Ms.Hansen, it’s been a while.”
“Well don’t just stand there, you came just in time I was making cookies!” That’s what the smell was, Peanut Butter Cookies. Evan’s favorites.
“Ms.Hansen, there’s something I need to tell you…”
“Can you wait a minute? I don’t want the cookies to burn.”
“Oh yeah, course.”
“You can go take a seat in the living room I’ll be out in a few minutes.” Nodding Jared made his way to said room. It was overwhelming, everything was exactly the same with the exception of the quietness of the house. That was until he heard another voice coming from the living room.
“-atever you say Evan.” Jared stopped looking around the corner and stopped dead in his tracks. There on the couch sat Connor Murphy talking to the empty air next to him.
“What the fuck?”