Madoka: I mean, you could fight her. You could totally kick her ass. And she would let you. You could fight Madoka, but at your own risk. Both Homura and Sayaka will kill you to moment you touch a hair on her head. I wouldn’t fight Madoka if I were you.
Homura: y'know what? Before watching rebellion, I would have said something like ‘why would you want to fight her? Hasn’t she been through enough?’ But now I will literally pay you to fight her. Do it. You’ll lose. She will beat your ass into the ground but it would be worth it. Fucking fight Homura please do it.
Mami: why would you do that. Why would you fight Mami. She’s sweet and kind and has a heart of gold. The only one who is purer than her is Madoka. Also she could kill you without a regret. Don’t fight Mami.
Sayaka: don’t do it. DO NOT FIGHT HER. She’ll fucking stab you right away. Plus she can heal herself super quickly. So even if she doesn’t kill you right off the bat, you could hardly hurt her. Please don’t fight Sayaka don’t do that to yourself.
Kyoko: no. Just no. Don’t fucking fight Kyoko she will kill you and then turn you into a fucking meme. Don’t fight her.
Kyubey: you should fight him. Do it. You could do. If you’re fast enough you could totally do it. You’d have to do it 9 times but the satisfaction should make it worth it. Fight Kyubey.
Hitomi: oh boy please fight Hitomi. You could beat her up really easily you fucking could. And I’m sure you’d want to. Punch her right in her stupid mouth maybe that’ll shut her up. Please fight Hitomi.
Kyosuke: you could fight him. I mean, if you want to fight a crippled kid. Fight Kyosuke if you’re a sick fuck.
Never being able to understand why Sayaka is so “selfish” for wishing to heal Kyosuke. I’ve watched the show over and over again, and I still don’t understand the reasoning behind it. She could have easily made a wish that would have stripped him of his free will and forced him to love her back, but she didn’t. In the finale, she even lets him go and gives Hitomi her blessing!
OH MY GOD STOP SAYING KYOSUKE IS A DOUCHE LIKE SERIOUSLY STOP
JUST BECAUSE SAYAKA MADE A WISH TO SAVE HIM DOESN'T MAKE HIM OBLIGATED TO LIKE HER. Y'KNOW WHAT KINDA LOGIC YOU’RE USING? A GUY THAT TAKES A GIRL OUT, PAYS FOR HER AND EXPECTS SOMETHING IN RETURN. TAKE YOUR FUCKIN’ FEDORAS OFF MY FRIENDS.
IN THE GAME HE EVEN EXPRESSED TAHT HE MIGHT HAVE FEELINGS FOR HER BUT HIS OWN LACK OF SELF CONFIDENCE STOPPED HIM FROM ACTING. HE THOUGHT SAYAKA WOULDN’T LIKE SOMEONE LIKE HIM.
AND THEN THIS NICE GIRL HE’S KNOWN FOR AWHILE ASKS HIM OUT AND WHAT’S WRONG WITH THAT? HITOMI WAS FUCKIN’ REAL W/ SAYAKA ABOUT IT AND SHE DID NOTHING. KYOSUKE IS NOT FUCKING OBLIGATED TO DATE SAYAKA, NO MATTER HOW MUCH SHE’S HURTING. STOP MAKING HIM OUT TO BE SOME HEARTLESS, SELF ABSORBED DOUCHEBAG.
How people are always quick to call Madoka and Hitomi “horrible friends” and say that “Kyosuke should have caught on sooner”. but never actually hold Sayaka accountable for some of the actions leading up to her falling into despair. She was a lot more responsible for it than any of those other people, because she chose to contract Kyubey, she chose not to tell Kyosuke her feelings for him, and she chose to let her Soul Gem darken past the point of no return.