I don’t know if this makes sense, and I especially don’t know if the writers are mapping out Sonny’s character arc in such detail, but something occured to me after rewatching this week’s episode.
Sonny seemed to be taking a separate position, more than once, compared to the other cops (even Benson).
First of all, like I said in my earlier post, Sonny asked for a warrant before he even went to search the poor guy’s apartment, and Benson practically said “find something linking him to the rape, forget about the warrant”. Then, as he was searching the apartment, he was acting all intense but it was clear he was fronting, it was clear that he was panicking because, after some point, he started realizing they had shot the wrong guy.
That’s why he asked about the guy’s haircut; because, even though Sonny was supposed to be trying to pin the crime on the suspect, he was actually trying to figure out if the guy was guilty. Which he wasn’t. That’s why Sonny asked about a warrant again, for a second time, on the phone with Benson (and she shut him down again); he knew they were searching that apartment of an innocent man. There’d be nothing there.
But Sonny stood apart one more time; at the end of the episode, when all the other cops were openly dissing Barba, Sonny was the only one who spoke up to defend him. Even Rollins was quiet, or just focusing on the ‘silver lining’ (for her and her cop friends), on the fact the cops would probably walk.
Sonny didn’t act like an angry cop; he considered the facts, and he correctly deduced that Barba never would have overcharged like that, so it must have been the grand jury.
So, twice in one episode, Sonny was shown to act differently than the rest of the cops. Could that be because he’s more than just a cop? Could this be a hint that Sonny might be considering becoming a lawyer? That he’s not as hardcore as the other cops, because maybe he doesn’t necessarily see himself as a cop in the long term?
Could that be why Sonny was the only one who empathized with Barba? What do you think?
It’s complete puzzling that Barba even needs to be defended here? He was doing his job? Is there a reason that it is okay for everyone else to do their job but not Barba? Why is everyone suddenly so far up Tucker’s ass that the hate needs to be directed towards the guy who always does his job no matter what.
This is who Barba is. This is who Barba has always been. Liv is a friend but she is not above the law. He’s not going to take that risk for someone who couldn’t even let him in on the little secret? Nothing he did was malicious or out of jealousy, but you can’t expect him to go the extra mile for someone who wasn’t upfront in the first place. I love Liv and she had reasons, but don’t hold Barba to some higher standard.