I'm just saying...
It seems pretty damn possible that Ali is the one who moved that game into her own house, or at least like knew it was going to be there.
1. She has a key to the barn.
2. She sorta created a situation for Aria and her to go in the kitchen and find the game. She asks her if she’s eaten and when Aria says she’s not really hungry, she kinda presses it with “that’s not what I asked.”
I get that that is totally a concerned mom thing to say, but if she had just let her go to bed instead, then she couldn’t have guaranteed Aria was there when Ali “discovered” it.
3. Seriously how TF did she not notice something that huge sitting on her table? I mean, it’s a pretty open floor plan. It’s literally RIGHT behind where she’s standing, and it’s the size of a coffee table.