Torn Part 1 — Sweet Pea x Reader & Jughead x Reader
Summary: You are Tall Boy’s daughter and have been best friends with Sweet Pea since you were in diapers. You’ve had a crush on him since you can remember, but when Jughead and Betty break up he shows interest in you. Who will you choose?
A/N: I was originally going to make this triangle with Sweet Pea and FP (because they’re obviously my favorite two guys and if you like the idea I can still write it) there shouldn’t be any warnings except swearing, drinking, and hints of smut.
I was sitting at the Whyte Wyrm with Toni sipping beers, but I wasn’t listening to her; I was watching Sweet Pea who was trying to pick up some Northside trash that wandered in, “earth to Y/N,” Toni said waving a hand in my face.
“Sorry, what were you saying?”
“You know he’s clueless right?”
“He’s just not interested,” we had a conversation the other night and he said he ‘wasn’t ready.’ I may not have been the most experienced with guys, but I knew that was bull shit.
“Then it’s his loss. Let’s get drunk and forget about him.” She waved to the bartender and ordered two shots, “leave the bottle,” she instructed him.
After a few shots and some girl talk Jughead joined us, “how are you lovely ladies doing?” He pulled up a bar stool and sat between us.
“We are in the process of forgetting,” Toni said.
“Can I join you?” Toni and I nodded. We took shot after shot, but Toni couldn’t keep up, “I think I’m going home. I can’t take another sip.” She left Jughead and I alone.
“You know, you look beautiful tonight.” Jughead said out of nowhere.
I could feel my face turn red, “Thanks.”
“Do you want to go to my place? It looks like the party is dying here.”
I looked around and he was right. The bar was nearly empty; except Sweet Pea, Fangs, and my dad. Fangs and my dad were engaged in a heated conversation, but Pea’s eyes were on Jughead and I, “I’d love to.” Jughead wrapped his arm around me and we walked back to his trailer.
The next day. Sweet Pea’s POV
I dialed Y/N’s number and called. Straight to voicemail, “fuck,” I threw my phone across the room. Just then it rang. I raced across the room to answer and without looking I picked it up, “Y/N?”
“Caller ID genius, it’s Toni.”
“Oh, hey.” My disappointment was obvious.
“You really know how to make a girl feel loved. What’s wrong?”
“She left the bar last night with Jughead.”
“He was probably just walking her home.”
“He was kissing her!”
“They probably hooked up. Why do you have a stick up your ass?”
“Because I like her,” my voice filled with sadness.
“You rejected her. Sweet Pea you can’t keep her on standby until you magically feel ready.”
“I know I was an ass.”
“You need to let this play out. There’s nothing you can do.”
“The hell there isn’t. I’ll talk to you later.” I hung up the phone and looked outside my window towards FP’s trailer. “She’s still there,” I whispered to myself. Not thinking I stormed over there and pounded on the door.
“What do you want?” Jughead rudely asked. “We’re busy.”
“I need to talk to Y/N. Now!”
“Sweets? What are you doing here?” She poked her head out of the door from behind Jughead. She was just in her jeans and a bra. My stomach dropped. “Jughead can you give us a second?”
“Yeah,” he walked out of sight.
“I needed to talk to you.”
“I’m listening.” But instead of talking I kissed her without thinking. She stepped outside letting the door close behind her, not breaking the kiss at first, but then she did, “what are we doing? I need to go.” She opened the door and grabbed her jacket not even bothering to put on a shirt, “Jughead I have to go home she called to him across the trailer.”
“Y/N?” I asked.
“I need to go. This,” she motioned in a circle,” is too much right now.”
I called Toni, “he kissed me,” being incredibly vague.
“You stayed at Jughead’s and he only kissed you?” Toni was unimpressed.
“No,” I told her the story.
“What are you going to do?”
“I have no idea what should I do?”
A/N: okay guys there will be a part two, but I want to know who you guys think should win Y/N’s affection. Comment your opinion please! Hopefully you like this story!